Shin Bet Chief's Demands to Investigate Arab MKs Rejected
Translated & summarized from Mako by baba
Shin Bet chief David Zinai clashed with senior legal officials over demands to investigate Arab Knesset members and halt election results due to alleged foreign interference. The Attorney General and prosecutors rejected Zinai's requests, citing a lack of evidence and describing the investigation as "collapsing." Despite these rejections and a judge's ruling that the suspicions did not affect the election's integrity, Zinai reportedly continues to push for the investigation.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Shin Bet chief David Zinai demanded to investigate Arab MKs and block election results over foreign interference claims.
- Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara and prosecutors rejected Zinai's demands, citing lack of evidence.
- Attendees described Zinai's conduct during a meeting as a "horror show."
- A judge ruled that the alleged foreign interference did not impact the election results.
- Senior legal officials stated the Shin Bet investigation was "collapsing" and lacked evidence of election theft.
Shin Bet chief David Zinai engaged in a severe and unprecedented confrontation with senior legal officials after demanding authorization to investigate Arab Knesset members and halt the publication of election results, citing foreign interference. Zinai allegedly presented intelligence suggesting foreign influence, particularly from Qatar, affecting tens of thousands of votes, which he described as "the biggest attack on Israeli democracy."
A late-night meeting on October 31, days after the election, at the Ministry of Justice saw Zinai present his demands to top officials from the Justice Ministry, the State Prosecutor's Office, and the Police Investigations Department. Attendees described Zinai's conduct as a "horror show," with some legal officials noting that the Shin Bet's investigation was "collapsing" and lacked evidence of election theft. The Shin Bet, however, maintained that the suspicions were serious and that the organization was acting within its legal authority.
Zinai insisted on obtaining approvals to investigate Arab party leaders and use Shin Bet tools against them, including wiretapping five Knesset members, by November 4, the legal deadline for publishing election results. These demands were rejected by Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara and other senior prosecutors, who argued they lacked evidentiary basis. One participant called the attempt to complete such an investigation in a few days "delusional."
During the discussion, a senior prosecutor requested intelligence on Qatar for the "Qatargate" affair, which involves Prime Minister's Office personnel, but Zinai refused. A senior law enforcement official claimed that an event planned for election day, including arrests without warrants, was intended to boost the election campaign, and a second event concerning alleged foreign interference was planned for the day after.
Following Judge Solberg's determination that the suspicions did not impact the election's integrity, a senior law enforcement official stated that the Shin Bet investigation was "collapsing" and that they prevented the Shin Bet from continuing what they called "madness," fearing it could become a tool to suppress political rivals. Despite these findings, Zinai reportedly continues to insist on reviving the investigation, claiming sufficient evidence exists.