Ex-German Official Notes Politicians' Calculations on Small Jewish Voting Bloc
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
Former German official Michael Roth observed a shift in his party's stance on Israel, with colleagues opting for silence due to electoral calculations and rising anti-Israel sentiment. Roth criticized Prime Minister Netanyahu but cautioned against blaming all of Israel, noting that many Germans still support the country. He urged realism, stating that the fight against terror will continue regardless of Israeli leadership, and criticized the blurring of lines between opposing Netanyahu and opposing Israel.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Former German official Michael Roth noted politicians' silence on Israel due to electoral calculations.
- Roth criticized Prime Minister Netanyahu but warned against holding all of Israel responsible.
- He observed a rise in anti-Israel sentiment within his own party's left-leaning faction.
- Roth urged realism, stating the fight against terror will continue regardless of Israeli leadership.
- He criticized the loss of distinction between opposing Netanyahu and opposing Israel.
Michael Roth, former Chairman of the Bundestag's Foreign Affairs Committee and German Minister of State for Europe, has observed a shift in political sentiment within his party regarding Israel, particularly since the Hamas attack on October 7. Roth, long a prominent voice in Germany supporting Israel and combating antisemitism, noted that even senior party members who share his views are now opting for silence. He attributes this to electoral considerations and the rise of anti-Israel sentiments on the left.
Roth, who claims to have personally paid a price for his pro-Israel stance, expressed strong criticism of Prime Minister Netanyahu. However, he cautioned against holding all of Israel responsible, stating, "You have more friends in Germany than the loud debates suggest." He also highlighted the disconnect between behind-the-scenes support for Israel and public willingness to defend it.
Speaking ahead of his participation in the ELNET conference in Jerusalem from November 22-24, which will gather over 200 European leaders, parliament members, and diplomats, Roth addressed the perception that a change in Israeli leadership would fundamentally alter the security situation. "What I want to bring back to Berlin is a bit of realism," he said. "Many Germans hope that everything will be much better once Mr. Netanyahu leaves. I hope so too. But Israelis want security and peace without terror, so the fight against Hamas and other terror organizations will continue, regardless of who heads the government. People in Berlin need to understand this."
Roth criticized Netanyahu's performance, stating, "I was never a supporter of Mr. Netanyahu. He fell into every trap and did nothing to change the image of the 'bad Israeli.'" He warned that in Germany, the distinction between opposing Netanyahu and opposing Israel is being lost, leading to a complete absence of positive remarks about Israel and the unfair imposition of responsibility on German Jews for events in Jerusalem.