Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Day 2

Rabbi Yehuda Gilad: Separate Composer From His Work, Embrace Diverse Melodies in Prayer

2 developments

NEWSru IsraelCulture

Rabbi Backs Using Secular Melodies for Prayers, Citing Tradition

Translated & summarized from NEWSru Israel by baba

CommunityNeutral tone

Russian · 1 newsroom

Rabbi Yehuda Gilad supports using secular melodies, including those by Shlomo Carlebach, for synagogue prayers, advocating for separating the music from the composer's controversial legacy. He cited the historical precedent set by Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, who permitted adapting secular tunes, contrasting with Rabbi Eliezer Yehuda Waldenberg's opposition. Gilad believes music that enhances spiritual focus and joy is valuable, unless its origin is overtly immoral. Carlebach's music remains influential despite accusations of misconduct against him.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Rabbi Yehuda Gilad supports using secular melodies for prayers, including those by Shlomo Carlebach.
  • Gilad advocates separating Carlebach's music from his controversial personal conduct.
  • He cited Rabbi Ovadia Yosef's historical permission to adapt secular tunes for religious use.
  • Rabbi Eliezer Yehuda Waldenberg previously opposed using secular song melodies in synagogues.
  • Carlebach's music has greatly influenced global synagogue music despite misconduct accusations.
  • Gilad believes music enhancing prayer focus and joy has spiritual value.

Rabbi Yehuda Gilad, head of the religious-Zionist yeshiva Ma'ale Gilboa, has voiced support for using melodies composed by Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach in synagogue prayers, despite ongoing controversy surrounding Carlebach's personal conduct. During a Halakha lesson, Rabbi Gilad argued for separating the composer's personality from his musical legacy.

He referenced a historical debate between two prominent 20th-century authorities: Rabbi Eliezer Yehuda Waldenberg and former Sephardic Chief Rabbi of Israel Ovadia Yosef. Rabbi Waldenberg opposed using melodies from love songs in synagogues, fearing that familiar tunes would distract worshippers and lead to inappropriate thoughts. Conversely, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef permitted such practices, citing the centuries-old Sephardic tradition of singing "Bakkashot" (night liturgical hymns), which regularly adapted secular Eastern songs for religious texts.

Rabbi Gilad endorsed a more flexible approach, stating that prayer is a lifelong spiritual endeavor. He believes any music that awakens joy and aids deeper concentration on the meaning of words possesses spiritual value. Rabbi Gilad suggested that secular melodies should not be broadly prohibited for prayer unless their original source involves grossly immoral or indecent content incompatible with a synagogue's atmosphere.

Shlomo Carlebach (1925-1994) was an American rabbi, composer, and performer who created hundreds of melodies that significantly influenced modern synagogue music globally. After his death, several women accused Carlebach of sexual harassment and misconduct, leading some communities to cease performing his works.

NEWSru IsraelOther · Tel Aviv

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

CultureTopic

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Related stories · 1

Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.

Open the Wire