US Peace Council Frustrated with Israel Over Gaza Plan
Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba
A senior advisor for the Peace Council, Josh Greenbaum, voiced frustration with the Israeli government for delaying a US-backed plan to rehabilitate Gaza and disarm Hamas. Greenbaum stated that Hamas has agreed to the plan, but Israel's lack of reciprocal commitment is stalling progress. He warned that continued delays could lead to Israel bearing full responsibility for Gaza's humanitarian crisis and potential return to Hamas rule, urging immediate action on key aspects of the plan.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Peace Council advisor Josh Greenbaum expressed frustration with Israel over stalled Gaza rehabilitation and Hamas disarmament plan.
- Hamas has verbally agreed to the plan, but Israel has not provided reciprocal commitments, according to Greenbaum.
- The Peace Council warned Israel could face full humanitarian costs for Gaza or its return to Hamas.
- Greenbaum urged Israel to immediately sign an agreement for an International Stabilization Force in Gaza.
- He stressed that the opportunity with a supportive US administration is closing due to Israeli political delays.
A senior advisor for the Peace Council, Josh Greenbaum, expressed significant frustration with the Israeli government's perceived inaction regarding a 20-point plan for Gaza's rehabilitation and Hamas's disarmament, a plan initially championed by former President Donald Trump.
Greenbaum stated that the international community, including the UN Security Council and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, had backed Trump's initiative as the only viable path forward for Gaza. He noted that while the Israeli government and Prime Minister Netanyahu initially accepted the plan, progress has stalled, leading to a rare consensus among the Trump administration, the EU, Israeli security officials, and the Peace Council that the Israeli government is obstructing it.
The Peace Council presented a briefing indicating that Hamas is far from collapse and that Israel is delaying the process. The presentation outlined alternative scenarios for Gaza's future, including potential future US administrations, the UN (possibly through UNRWA), or the Palestinian Authority, and warned that if Israel does not proceed with the current plan, it will bear full administrative and humanitarian costs for Gaza, potentially leading to its return to Hamas or a UN mandate.
Greenbaum highlighted that Hamas had formally accepted the Peace Council's plan in July, agreeing to disarm and transfer governance to a technocratic Palestinian government. However, he criticized Israel for refusing to provide reciprocal commitments, which prevents testing Hamas's sincerity. He warned that continued delays would result in deeper diplomatic isolation for Israel, potential sanctions, and eroding support in Washington, especially with a less sympathetic future administration.
Greenbaum emphasized that the plan is not based on trust in Hamas but on verifiable actions and commitments. He urged Israel to immediately sign an agreement for the International Stabilization Force (ISF) to operate in Gaza, allow Palestinian security forces to train in Egypt for future governance, and facilitate humanitarian aid before winter. He stressed that the window of opportunity with a supportive US president is closing, and political considerations within Israel are hindering progress on national security interests.
Mentioned