Haredi Youths' Aggression Highlights Draft Exemption Debate
Translated & summarized from Zman Yisrael by baba
A personal encounter with aggressive Haredi youths has fueled the author's criticism of proposed draft exemptions for the Haredi community. He argues that only exceptional Torah scholars deserve exemptions, while military service could benefit others. The article criticizes political leaders, particularly Avigdor Lieberman, for allegedly compromising on draft reform promises to gain Haredi support, suggesting the negotiations are disingenuous and that Haredim are poised to win broad exemptions.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Author recounts being verbally attacked by Haredi youths, questioning their education and suitability for military service.
- Proposals for broad Haredi draft exemptions are criticized as unwarranted for most students.
- Political leaders, including Avigdor Lieberman, are accused of compromising on draft reform for Haredi support.
- Haredi community is seen as poised to benefit significantly from current political negotiations on draft exemptions.
- A senior Haredi commentator described the draft exemption talks as a "big fake."
The author recounts an aggressive encounter with a group of seven to eight Haredi teenagers, aged 17-18, who verbally assaulted him with vulgar curses and threats after he responded to their question about his political leanings. The incident, which occurred as the youths were returning to their yeshiva, prompted the author to question the values and education imparted in such institutions, particularly in light of ongoing political discussions about draft exemptions for the Haredi community.
The author criticizes the proposals by Avigdor Lieberman and others in the "change bloc" to grant broad draft exemptions to Haredim, arguing that such leniency is unwarranted for those who do not demonstrate exceptional Torah scholarship. He suggests that military service could foster better character development and integration into society for most Haredi youths, transforming them from "ruffians in Shabbat hats" into more well-rounded individuals.
The article notes that while Gadi Eisenkot is willing to exempt about 3% of each conscription class, Haredi leaders are reportedly seeking blanket exemptions for all. The author believes that prominent rabbis could identify true Torah prodigies deserving of exemption, but accuses community leaders of avoiding this selective process.
Furthermore, the piece criticizes the "change bloc" leaders, especially Lieberman, for allegedly compromising their pre-election commitments by offering concessions to the Haredi community regarding draft exemptions. It suggests that these negotiations are largely disingenuous, citing a senior Haredi commentator who described the talks as a "big fake." The article concludes that the Haredi community, like the Arab community, stands to benefit most from the current political climate, potentially achieving full draft exemption and undermining efforts for equal burden-sharing.
Mentioned