Freedom Without Responsibility Can Lead to Dictatorship, Says Researcher
Translated & summarized from Alarab by baba
Researcher Rafeh Halabi asserts that freedom without responsibility can lead to dictatorship, emphasizing that democracy requires a balance of rights and duties for all citizens. He criticizes actions that undermine state institutions and symbols, while commending efforts towards political participation and shared citizenship. Halabi calls for mutual respect, equality, and responsible exercise of freedom, arguing that true belonging is demonstrated through actions, not just words.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Freedom without responsibility can devolve into dictatorship, threatening democratic foundations, according to researcher Rafeh Halabi.
- Democracy is a system of reciprocal rights and duties, requiring respect for laws and institutions from all citizens.
- Citizenship involves active participation and responsibility, not just the enjoyment of rights or expression of identity.
- Political actions should be evaluated based on programs and results, not national affiliation or rhetoric.
- True belonging is demonstrated through daily actions and respect for institutions, not solely through words or slogans.
- A shared citizenship framework is needed to balance state symbols with cultural diversity and mutual respect.
Researcher Rafeh Halabi argues that freedom is not merely the absence of constraints but a value intrinsically linked to awareness and responsibility. He contends that true freedom is realized when individuals understand that their rights are balanced by duties, and that personal autonomy does not grant the right to infringe upon the dignity or security of others. Halabi warns that freedom without responsibility can devolve into a form of dictatorship, particularly when it shifts from a mutual right to a unilateral privilege, threatening the foundations of democracy.
Halabi emphasizes that democracy is a comprehensive system of rights and obligations, freedom of expression and accountability, and political participation alongside adherence to public life regulations. He asserts that citizenship is not merely an identity card or a formal pledge but a reciprocal relationship between the individual and the state, built on mutual respect for laws and institutions, and a shared understanding of societal security and individual dignity.
He further distinguishes between legitimate political criticism and disloyalty, stating that criticizing the government does not equate to opposition to the state or nation. However, he stresses that these rights do not negate responsibility, and that democracy does not grant immunity for inciting hatred, justifying violence, or violating others' dignity. True belonging, he explains, is demonstrated through daily actions and respect for institutions and laws, not just words or slogans.
Halabi commends the United Arab List's approach under Mansour Abbas for focusing on political participation and parliamentary work to serve the public interest. Conversely, he expresses criticism towards certain actions by leaders in the Joint List, particularly perceived inconsistencies between participating in state institutions and showing insufficient respect for their symbols and official occasions. He advocates for evaluating political stances based on programs, actions, and results, rather than national affiliation.
The researcher also addresses the parliamentary oath, viewing it as a commitment to public responsibility and adherence to the state's legal and institutional framework. He argues that while opposition is a vital part of democracy, the oath imposes a duty to respect constitutional rules and the institution itself. Similarly, he discusses national symbols like the Israeli national anthem, acknowledging that Arab citizens may not identify with its nationalistic content but stressing the importance of respecting state institutions. He criticizes the act of some Arab Knesset members leaving during the anthem, seeing it as politically unwise for representatives working within the legislative system, while advocating for a shared citizenship framework that respects both state symbols and cultural diversity.
Finally, Halabi concludes that true democracy requires mutual responsibility, ensuring equal rights and obligations for all citizens, regardless of their national or political affiliation. He calls for a political culture that builds bridges, manages differences constructively, and fosters genuine partnership based on mutual respect, shared responsibilities, and the understanding that freedom is a right that must be exercised responsibly, without infringing on the rights and dignity of others.