Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Day 75

Ultra-Orthodox Parties Demand Full Draft Exemption Without Sanctions

14 developments

MaarivPolitics

Ultra-Orthodox Draft Law is Just the Beginning of Deeper Challenges

Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba

CenterCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

The ultra-Orthodox draft law is a symptom of deeper economic and demographic issues, according to analyst Dan Peri. He argues that the current system of exemptions for yeshiva students is unsustainable and requires government intervention through policy and budget conditions. While coalition negotiations present risks of perpetuating the problem, potential compromises involving Arab parties like Ra'am could offer a path forward, even if it means delaying reforms. The author stresses that the challenge extends beyond military service to the economic integration and future funding of essential services for all citizens.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • The ultra-Orthodox draft law is a symptom of larger economic and demographic threats from the Haredi model.
  • Only half of Haredi men are employed, often in low-wage or fictitious jobs, hindering economic integration.
  • The Haredi population's rapid growth strains national resources for security, health, and education.
  • Solutions involve mandating core curriculum studies and reducing subsidies for prolonged yeshiva study.
  • Coalition negotiations risk perpetuating the problem, but compromise with Arab parties is a potential path.
  • The challenge extends beyond military service to economic integration and future national funding.

The recent draft law for the ultra-Orthodox community is merely a symptom of a larger economic and demographic threat posed by the Haredi model, according to analyst Dan Peri. While Gadi Eisenkot, the Minister of Defense, may compromise on the pace of change regarding military service, he must not perpetuate the problem, the author argues. The current system, where the slogan "Torato Umnuto" (his Torah is his craft) grants near-automatic exemption to yeshiva students, is deemed a moral injustice, with exceptions only for a limited number of outstanding scholars. The core issue, however, extends beyond military conscription to the economic and demographic implications of the Haredi community's lifestyle. Only about half of Haredi men of working age are employed, often in fictitious roles funded by taxpayers, and their average wages are significantly lower. Many lack essential skills like English, math, and science due to an educational system that hinders integration into the modern economy. This is compounded by incentives that encourage prolonged yeshiva study over employment, creating generational economic dependency subsidized by the state. Public expenditure per Haredi household can reach nearly 11,500 shekels monthly, including benefits and government services.

The demographic challenge is equally pressing. The Haredi population, already one-sixth of Israel's total, is growing rapidly due to a high birth rate of over six children per family. This unchecked growth threatens the nation's ability to fund essential services like security, healthcare, infrastructure, and education for all citizens. The author warns that this situation is unsustainable and could lead to economic collapse, potentially driving away the productive sector of the economy.

Solutions proposed include mandating core curriculum studies (math, English, science) in all publicly funded educational institutions, with funding contingent on adequate instruction. Support for adult men remaining in yeshivas indefinitely should be gradually reduced, reserving limited frameworks for genuine Torah scholars. Indirect subsidies encouraging avoidance of work should be cut, and child benefit structures re-examined to protect poor families. The author believes change must come through government policy, budget conditions, and economic incentives, rather than relying on dialogue with rabbinical leadership, which fears losing control over the community if general education and economic independence increase.

The current coalition negotiations present a significant risk. There's a concern that a government formed to replace Binyamin Netanyahu might perpetuate the existing system by acceding to Haredi demands for continued funding of non-core curriculum institutions, maintaining current religious-state arrangements, and preserving Haredi autonomy. Such concessions could block reform for years. However, the political reality might necessitate compromises, potentially including a government comprising Eisenkot's bloc, the Haredi parties, and Ra'am, with parliamentary cooperation from the Joint List. This could create a coalition of up to 80 members of Knesset, allowing Avigdor Lieberman to present a government not dependent on Ra'am, while enabling significant political participation for Arab citizens. Mansour Abbas has expressed willingness to meet Eisenkot's "four conditions." Rejecting this opportunity could deepen alienation among Arab citizens and portray Israel as a racist state.

While such a broad government might delay dramatic reforms in the Haredi sector, it would avoid actively thwarting them. Gradual conscription agreements, avoiding immediate budget conflicts, and maintaining coalition stability are possible, provided the principle of core curriculum studies for public funding is upheld. At a minimum, the government could avoid expanding subsidies that encourage idleness and providing guarantees that hinder future reforms.

An alternative scenario involves the Haredi parties presenting impossible demands, such as a permanent conscription exemption, guarantees against core curriculum studies, or an override clause to bypass Supreme Court rulings. In such a case, Eisenkot would need to draw a clear line, as undermining democratic foundations is too high a price for forming a government. If negotiations fail, forming a government with Arab parties, including Ra'am, might become necessary, even for Lieberman, given the lack of alternatives. This would be a crucial choice for Israel's future, with Eisenkot's true test being broader than just the number of Haredi recruits.

MaarivCentre · Jerusalem

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire