Court Rejects State's Bid for NIS 6 Million from Ex-Yisrael Beiteinu Officials
Translated & summarized from Behadrei Haredim by baba
The Tel Aviv District Court dismissed a civil lawsuit by the state seeking NIS 6 million from former Yisrael Beiteinu officials Faina Kirshenbaum and Rami Cohen. The state claimed compensation for bribery and coalition funds transferred as part of a corruption case. The court found the state failed to prove financial damages from coalition fund transfers and that personal bribery funds were already confiscated. The ruling also noted the defendants' existing prison sentences and ordered the state to pay their legal costs.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Tel Aviv court dismissed state's NIS 6 million lawsuit against Faina Kirshenbaum and Rami Cohen.
- The lawsuit sought compensation for bribery and coalition funds from the Yisrael Beiteinu corruption case.
- The court ruled the state did not prove financial damages from coalition fund transfers.
- Personal bribery funds sought were already confiscated in the criminal proceedings, the court found.
- The state was ordered to pay NIS 10,000 in legal costs to each defendant.
A Tel Aviv District Court has dismissed a civil lawsuit filed by the state against Faina Kirshenbaum, former Deputy Interior Minister and Secretary-General of Yisrael Beiteinu, and Rami Cohen, former Director-General of the Ministry of Agriculture. The state had sought approximately NIS 6 million in compensation following their convictions in the Yisrael Beiteinu corruption case. The lawsuit, filed in December 2022, was based on the pair's convictions for corruption offenses, including bribery and money laundering.
The state aimed to recover funds from bribery and benefits, as well as coalition funds transferred to various bodies as part of the affair. Approximately NIS 5 million of the total sum was claimed for budgets allocated to the Shomron Development Company, the Handball Association, and the Basketball Association. An additional NIS 1.1 million was sought from Kirshenbaum for bribery and benefits, after deducting NIS 1 million already confiscated from her in the criminal proceedings.
Judge Yossi Barkai ruled that the state failed to prove that the transfer of coalition funds caused the alleged financial damage. The ruling clarified that while the budgets were allocated as part of corrupt acts, it was not proven that these funds would have remained with the state had the defendants not acted as they did, rather than being transferred to other entities. Regarding the bribery funds, the court determined that the amounts personally received by Kirshenbaum were already covered by the confiscation in the criminal proceedings. The remaining funds sought by the state had been partially transferred to other parties, and no grounds were established to compel Kirshenbaum to return them.
The judge also referenced the sentences already imposed on the two. In the criminal proceedings, Kirshenbaum received seven and a half years in prison after an appeal, and Cohen received 18 months, along with fines and confiscations. Judge Barkai wrote in his ruling, "Not every outcome that can be described as the return of public funds is necessarily an outcome mandated by law. The law must indeed be enforced with determination but also with measure. The law does not strive for endless punishment."
Ultimately, the court rejected the lawsuit in its entirety and ordered the state to pay each defendant NIS 10,000 in legal expenses and attorney fees.
Mentioned
