War Rumor Industry Profiting From Public Anxiety
Translated & summarized from Globes by baba
Social media channels in Israel are profiting from spreading war rumors and speculation, exploiting public anxiety for financial gain. These "rumor industries" use sensationalized, often fabricated content to drive traffic and ad revenue, particularly on platforms like Telegram. While some users spread misinformation unknowingly, others do so intentionally. Experts note a global trend of disinformation for profit and strategic advantage, with limited legal oversight in Israel exacerbating the problem. Public sentiment is shifting from fear to weariness and anger towards rumor mongers.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Social media channels profit from spreading war rumors by exploiting public anxiety and driving ad revenue.
- Fabricated content, often mixed with real news, is used to create panic and increase user engagement.
- Telegram is a primary platform for this "rumor industry," seeing a significant usage increase since October 7.
- Human psychology, particularly confirmation bias, contributes to the spread of misinformation.
- Public sentiment is shifting from fear to weariness and anger towards rumor mongers.
- A lack of legal and regulatory oversight in Israel allows these channels to operate with minimal accountability.
A lucrative business model, rather than sophisticated intelligence leaks or psychological warfare, is often behind the proliferation of war rumors and speculation on social media since October 7. Public anxiety is being monetized by operators of social media groups and news channels who have discovered that fear is the most marketable product, generating shares, increasing exposure, and capturing an audience.
The "rumor industry" operates with a calculated strategy targeting the public's emotional and security vulnerabilities. Messages are often framed with authoritative and mysterious tones, using phrases like "senior sources report" or "prepare your safe rooms," and include detailed extreme scenarios. These often feature specific dates for missile attacks, claims of defense system failures, or fabricated stories about secret reserve call-ups or infrastructure damage. To lend credibility, old videos, anonymous voice recordings, and edited screenshots of official messages are frequently incorporated. This content is mixed with real news, making it difficult for the average reader to distinguish between verified reports and manipulation. Commercial advertisements for purchases, financial investments, coupons, gambling, or product promotions immediately follow these dramatic alerts, driving users to return to the page repeatedly.
According to Idan Ring, a communication researcher, this economic model thrives on information vacuums and security ambiguity. He explains that unreliable "pseudo-news" sources spread viral information because their revenue depends on exposure. They post unverified indicators or incorrect videos, knowing it drives traffic. Telegram, with its high usage in Israel, has become a primary platform for this, experiencing a nearly 50% surge in usage since October 7. WhatsApp and Instagram are also significant platforms for this phenomenon.
Ring also points to human psychology, specifically confirmation bias, as a factor. People prone to fear seek information that confirms their anxieties, which these channels readily provide. Many individuals unknowingly contribute to the spread of misinformation by sharing warnings with family and friends or by wanting to be the first to disseminate information.
However, data from Yifat Vego, a social media analysis company, suggests a shift in public sentiment. While there are spikes in discussions about potential conflict with Iran, the actual fear index regarding an Iranian attack is low. Instead, a sense of weariness and public anger towards rumor mongers is emerging, with some even expressing a desire for the conflict to occur simply to end the uncertainty.
Operators of prominent Israeli Telegram channels admit that truth and factual accuracy are often sacrificed for public attention. They acknowledge that platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook, lacking the resources of established news organizations, resort to generating panic and fabricating or exaggerating headlines to increase traffic and revenue. Many channels, estimated at 95%, rely heavily on "copy-paste" tactics, spreading unverified information due to economic motives, lack of professionalism, or malicious intent. This creates a domino effect, where a single fabricated post can spread rapidly across networks, distorting public perception.
This disinformation economy is a global model, with a 2018 MIT study in *Science* finding that false news, especially that evoking strong emotions like fear, spreads six times faster than true news. The digital advertising industry reportedly funnels $2.6 billion annually to sites spreading false information. In Israel, this activity flourishes due to a significant legal and regulatory vacuum. Unlike established media, Telegram channels and WhatsApp groups operate in a legal gray area with little oversight or accountability for false reporting, undisclosed advertising, or promoting questionable products. The lack of enforcement incentivizes the creation of panic.
Beyond commercial interests, geopolitical actors also utilize rumors as strategic weapons. Professor Ron Schleifer notes that in modern warfare, rumors are part of deception and deterrence campaigns, citing Iran's use of "information warfare" and psychological tactics. He warns that this digital battleground, where all sides attempt to destabilize opponents, increases the risk of miscalculation.