Woman Left With Nothing After 17-Year Marriage and Two Children
Translated & summarized from Mako by baba
A woman has been left with no assets after a 17-year relationship and two children, following a Supreme Court decision that overturned previous rulings in her favor. Initially, a family court awarded her half of the marital property, but this was reversed by the District Court, which cited her infidelity. The District Court did grant her a penthouse, but the Supreme Court ultimately ruled the husband was not obligated to transfer it, leaving her with nothing. Her lawyer is seeking a further hearing.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- A woman was left with no assets after a 17-year relationship and two children.
- The Supreme Court overturned a lower court's decision to award the woman a penthouse.
- The woman's infidelity was cited by the District Court as grounds to revoke shared ownership.
- The family court had initially divided marital assets equally between the couple.
- The woman's lawyer is requesting a further hearing at the Supreme Court.
- The case involves asset division after a 17-year common-law relationship.
A woman has been left with nothing after a 17-year relationship and two children, following a protracted legal battle over marital assets. The couple, who married in a Reform ceremony and lived together managing a joint household, separated after 17 years due to marital issues.
Initially, the Tel Aviv Family Court ruled in favor of the woman, recognizing them as common-law partners and dividing four out of five properties acquired during their marriage equally. The court also split bank accounts and pension rights. This decision was partly influenced by the woman's father's financial difficulties, which led to assets being registered in the husband's name to protect them from creditors.
The husband appealed to the District Court, which overturned the initial ruling. The court cited the woman's romantic involvement with another person as grounds to revoke the shared ownership, deeming her conduct reprehensible. However, the District Court still awarded the woman a penthouse apartment, based on a WhatsApp message from the husband sent after their separation, indicating his intent to transfer ownership of the penthouse to her.
Both parties appealed to the Supreme Court. The woman contested the cancellation of shared ownership, while the husband challenged the transfer of the penthouse. The Supreme Court ultimately reversed the District Court's decision, ruling that the husband was not obligated to transfer the penthouse. Justice Willner stated that even if the message constituted a valid gift commitment, the husband could legally withdraw from it.
The woman has now requested a further hearing at the Supreme Court, seeking to establish a clear and just precedent for asset division in such cases. Her lawyer, Dr. Guy Carmi, stated that the Supreme Court's decision is legally and factually flawed and could lead to further injustices. He expressed hope that the court would grant the request for an expanded panel to review the case and shape clearer legal principles for asset division.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Coverage from Mako