Legal Advisor Draws Red Line on Ultra-Orthodox Draft Law and Arrest Freeze
Translated & summarized from Behadrei Haredim by baba
The legal advisor to the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Miri Frankel-Shoor, has stated she will not support a softened draft law for ultra-Orthodox conscription or a temporary freeze on arrests for yeshiva students. She previously opposed the previous coalition's draft law, citing unmet IDF needs and equality concerns. Frankel-Shoor emphasized that any draft law must include significant enforcement mechanisms to be defensible in the Supreme Court.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Legal advisor Miri Frankel-Shoor will not back a softened draft law for ultra-Orthodox conscription.
- She also opposes a temporary freeze on arrests for yeshiva students.
- Frankel-Shoor previously opposed the prior coalition's draft law.
- She stated a draft law needs significant enforcement to be defended in court.
- Negotiations are underway for a new government involving ultra-Orthodox parties.
The ultra-Orthodox party United Torah Judaism is currently engaged in negotiations with parties from the "Change Bloc" in an effort to form a new government. A key component of these discussions involves arranging the status of yeshiva students through a draft law that would withstand Supreme Court scrutiny. This issue is a significant crisis for the ultra-Orthodox community, with tens of thousands of individuals subject to conscription and facing potential arrest and severe sanctions.
Beyond the political maneuvering, a critical legal question looms: Will the legal advisors of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee and the Knesset endorse a softened draft law, as proposed by the "Change Bloc" parties? In the previous Knesset, these advisors opposed a draft law championed by the coalition, arguing it did not meet the IDF's needs, which had changed following the October 7th attacks, and that it violated the principle of equality.
Miri Frankel-Shoor, the legal advisor to the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, has provided a definitive answer. Having been a central figure in the legal opposition to the previous coalition's draft law, Frankel-Shoor stated that the identity of the government promoting the law is irrelevant. She clarified that even a more lenient draft law, this time originating from the "Change Bloc," would not receive her backing unless it included substantial enforcement mechanisms. "A toothless draft law, I will not defend it in the Supreme Court," Frankel-Shoor declared, adding, "I opposed Bismuth's draft law, and even more so a softer law."
Frankel-Shoor's stance extends beyond opposing a softened draft law. She has also drawn a red line against the possibility of passing a temporary law to freeze arrests of yeshiva students until a new draft law is finalized. She believes there is no justification for creating an alternative route to circumvent the conscription obligation, even as a temporary measure to allow a new government to stabilize and formulate a long-term solution. "I will not lend my hand to an alternative route to the draft law, neither temporarily nor under the pretext of a new government. The excuse of a new government does not change the constitutional situation," she explained.
Keep up with
Mentioned