Israel's Supreme Court Rejects Bid to Re-examine Journalist's Interview Materials
Translated & summarized from Ice by baba
Israel's Supreme Court has denied a request for a rehearing on journalistic privilege concerning unbroadcast interview materials. The ruling upholds a previous decision protecting raw footage from an interview with Eli Feldstein, conducted by journalist Omri Esneheim. The court stated that journalistic privilege extends to information gathered under trust, even if not broadcast. This decision is a setback for Yonatan Ourich and the police, who sought access to the materials for an investigation.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Supreme Court rejected a request for a rehearing on journalistic privilege for interview materials.
- The ruling protects unbroadcast footage from an interview with Eli Feldstein by Omri Esneheim.
- Journalistic privilege was extended to include information gathered under trust between a journalist and source.
- The decision is a victory for the Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation and journalist Omri Esneheim.
- Yonatan Ourich and the police had sought access to the raw interview materials.
The Israeli Supreme Court on Thursday rejected a request for an expanded panel to rehear a case concerning raw materials from an interview conducted by journalist Omri Esneheim with Eli Feldstein. This decision marks another victory for the Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation and Esneheim, who contested demands from Yonatan Ourich and the police to hand over unpublished interview footage.
Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Justice Noam Sohlberg, dismissed Ourich's plea for a rehearing, which followed a May ruling. The dispute centered on unbroadcast raw footage from Feldstein's interview, aired in December 2025 on Kan 11's "Yihye Tov" investigative program. Feldstein discussed classified documents leaked to the German newspaper "Bild" during the interview.
Initially, lower courts sided with the police's demand for the unbroadcast materials. However, the Supreme Court overturned this in May, extending journalistic privilege to include off-the-record information and raw materials gathered under trust between a journalist and a source. The court then required the police to submit a specific request detailing necessary materials for their investigation, rather than demanding all footage.
Subsequently, the police withdrew their request. However, Ourich proceeded to petition the Supreme Court for a rehearing. In his Thursday ruling, Sohlberg emphasized that rehearings are exceptional procedures for unique circumstances. He noted the police's opposition to a rehearing and stated that the expanded journalistic privilege is not absolute, allowing for its removal under specific conditions.
Sohlberg also addressed claims that the requirement for a specific request impedes police work, calling it an "insurmountable obstacle." He added that issues regarding the police's conduct in this specific investigation should be addressed in the main criminal proceedings, not in a request for a rehearing on journalistic privilege. The ruling upholds the May decision by President Yitzhak Amit and Justices Alex Stein and Khaled Kabub, which established that protection of trust between journalists and sources extends beyond source anonymity to include information and materials gathered during journalistic work.
Mentioned
