Tnuva Eyes Tomato Market, Intensifying Competition with Coca-Cola's Mutti Brand
Translated & summarized from Ice by baba
Israel's food industry is struggling with increased competition from cheaper imports due to eased regulations aimed at lowering living costs. Major domestic sectors like industrial vegetable cultivation are shrinking, with corn production drastically reduced. Tnuva is reportedly considering entering the imported tomato paste market, challenging Coca-Cola's Mutti brand. Farmers and manufacturers argue for government subsidies to support local production and ensure food security, warning against over-reliance on foreign suppliers.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Israel's food industry faces collapse amid competition from cheaper imports and lack of government support.
- Tnuva is considering entering the imported tomato paste market, challenging Coca-Cola's Mutti brand.
- Industrial corn production in Israel has fallen from 50,000 tons to 20,000 tons in three years.
- Farmers claim European industrial tomatoes are 30% cheaper than Israeli ones due to subsidies.
- The government is allocating duty-free quotas for yellow cheese imports to increase competition.
Israel's domestic food industry faces significant challenges due to relaxed import regulations aimed at combating the high cost of living. This has led to aggressive competition from cheaper foreign produce, pushing local farmers and manufacturers to the brink and threatening national food security. The industrial vegetable cultivation sector is particularly at risk, with over half of its output disappearing in the last three years. Corn cultivation, for instance, has plummeted from 50,000 tons to just 20,000 tons, and established factories like "Milouz" have closed.
Adding to this pressure, Tnuva, a major Israeli food producer, is reportedly considering entering the imported tomato paste market. This move would pit Tnuva against Coca-Cola, which imports the Italian brand "Mutti." Industry insiders and farmers argue that the competition from imports is unfair, as European, American, and Chinese agriculture receives substantial government subsidies, unlike Israeli farmers. Consequently, industrial tomatoes in Europe are 30% cheaper than in Israel, and subsidized corn from Hungary floods the market.
Chinese imports benefit from low energy costs, allowing Israeli importers to sell goods at or below cost to clear inventory. Major companies like Strauss, Sugat, Carrefour, and WilliFood are importing canned tomatoes, corn, and legumes from Italy, China, and Thailand. While some premium Italian brands remain expensive, imported corn brands are undercutting local producers like "Yakhin" and "Prininir."
Industry representatives warn that the current price reductions for consumers are temporary, with the long-term cost being the loss of agricultural independence. They caution that reliance on foreign countries for food supplies is risky, citing Turkey's export restrictions as a precedent. Instead of sacrificing local production, they advocate for government subsidies to Israeli farmers, which they claim could lower prices by 30%, preserve food factories, and ensure emergency supply.
In a related effort to boost competition and lower basic food prices, the Ministry of Economy and Industry has opened a tender for duty-free quotas for yellow cheese imports, totaling 5,900 tons for 2027. A significant portion will be allocated to importers committing to the lowest consumer prices.