El Al Appeals Supreme Court Ruling on Passenger Compensation
Translated & summarized from NEWSru Israel by baba
El Al Airlines is petitioning Israel's Supreme Court to overturn a district court ruling that requires it to pay 29,000 shekels for a passenger's 16-day accommodation during an airspace closure. The airline argues the law doesn't support unlimited liability when the state closes airspace. The passenger's representative contends El Al is trying to offload costs onto consumers. The case could set a precedent for airline responsibilities during national emergencies.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- El Al Airlines is appealing a district court ruling requiring 29,000 shekel compensation for passenger accommodation.
- The compensation covers 16 days of expenses incurred during an Israeli airspace closure in June-July 2025.
- The airline argues the state's airspace closure limits its operational ability and liability.
- A district court ruled El Al must cover all accommodation costs as no ministerial directive limited the duration.
- The case could establish precedent for airline responsibilities during national emergencies.
- Airlines have pending petitions seeking exemption from passenger assistance during airspace closures.
El Al Airlines has filed a petition with Israel's Supreme Court seeking to challenge a district court decision that ordered the airline to cover a passenger's accommodation expenses for 16 days during the "Pillar of Defense" operation, when Israeli airspace was closed. The compensation amount is 29,000 shekels. El Al is pursuing a principle-based ruling to define the scope of responsibility for air carriers.
The case involves passenger Ori Da'an and his family, who were flying to Krakow. Their return flight on June 17, 2025, was canceled due to the airspace closure on June 13, 2025, and they were only able to return on a rescue flight on July 2. Da'an initially sued El Al in small claims court for 16 days of expenses, including accommodation, transport, and food. The small claims court awarded compensation for only four nights of accommodation, but an appellate district court increased this to 16 nights.
The district court ruled that the airline must reimburse the passenger for all accommodation costs during the waiting period, even if it couldn't practically offer an alternative flight. The court noted that since the Transportation Minister had not issued a directive limiting accommodation to two nights, as permitted by the Aviation Services Law, the number of nights was not legally restricted.
El Al argues that the law does not mandate unlimited liability for airlines when the state closes airspace, preventing them from operating. The company believes such a ruling could deter foreign carriers from flying to Israel, reduce competition, and increase prices. El Al also mentioned that airlines have filed petitions with the High Court of Justice (BAGATS) seeking exemption from passenger assistance obligations during government-imposed airspace closures, but no decisions have been made yet.
The passenger's representative countered that El Al is attempting to shift economic burdens onto individual consumers. He stated that the Aviation Services Law is a consumer protection law with a mechanism for limiting accommodation in emergencies, but no such directive was issued during either the "Pillar of Defense" or "Operation Lion's Roar" operations.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Other 2
