British Commentator's Unanswerable Question for Pro-Palestinians
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
British commentator Constantin Kisin, host of the "Triggernometry" podcast, has publicly supported Israel's war in Gaza after previously maintaining neutrality. He challenges pro-Palestinian individuals with a question about how they would respond if their nation suffered an attack like October 7th, a question he claims they cannot answer. Kisin argues that many critics of Israel would advocate for a far more aggressive response in a similar situation, suggesting a double standard in their criticism.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Constantin Kisin, host of "Triggernometry," now supports Israel's war in Gaza.
- Kisin poses a question to pro-Palestinians about their response to a 7/10-like attack.
- He claims pro-Palestinian guests, like Bassem Youssef, evade answering the question.
- Kisin suggests critics of Israel would demand a harsher response in a similar scenario.
- His shift in stance has drawn accusations of bias and claims of Israeli government payment.
British author and political commentator Constantin Kisin, known for his popular podcast "Triggernometry," has shifted his stance on the Israel-Hamas war, publicly declaring his support for Israel. Kisin, who previously maintained neutrality, announced his change of position on October 7, 2024, explaining his reasoning in a detailed monologue. His shift is significant due to his global following and reputation for critical thinking.
Kisin and his co-host Francis Foster have hosted numerous guests on "Triggernometry" to discuss the Gaza conflict, including pro-Israel figures like Ben Shapiro and pro-Palestinian voices such as Norman Finkelstein. Kisin's recent video, "Why I Stopped Sitting on the Fence Regarding Israel's War," has sparked controversy, with critics accusing him of bias due to his Jewish heritage, despite being Orthodox Christian. Some have even alleged he receives payment from the Israeli government.
A central argument Kisin makes for his support of Israel is a question he claims pro-Palestinian individuals cannot answer: "If you were the Prime Minister of Israel and your country had just suffered the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust, with hundreds of civilians taken hostage, how would you respond?"
During an interview with Egyptian doctor and comedian Bassem Youssef, Kisin repeatedly posed this question. Youssef deflected by discussing historical grievances and what he would *not* do, such as committing genocide or targeting civilians, but never stated what he *would* do in Israel's position on October 8th. Kisin found this evasion, and similar responses from other guests, to be a demonstration of a double standard.
Kisin suggests that a hypothetical scenario where Mexico invaded Texas, killing tens of thousands and taking hostages, would elicit a far more aggressive response from the U.S. than Israel's current actions. He argues that the public reaction to 9/11 demonstrates a willingness for strong retaliation, contrasting it with the expectation of restraint placed upon Israel. Kisin urges pro-Israel advocates to pose this question to those criticizing Israel's response, highlighting potential hypocrisy if the answer involves a more severe reaction or an inability to answer the question directly.