EU Recognizes Israeli Fuel Tax as Carbon Levy, Averting Double Taxation
Translated & summarized from NEWSru Israel by baba
The European Union will recognize Israel's fuel excise tax as a carbon tax, preventing double taxation on Israeli exports. This agreement follows lengthy negotiations and will allow European importers to deduct the Israeli tax from CBAM obligations, provided a direct link to production emissions is proven. However, Israeli companies will face complex documentation requirements, and the Israeli tax is expected to cover only a fraction of the actual emission costs, according to environmental ministries and the OECD.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- EU recognizes Israel's fuel tax as a carbon tax, averting double taxation on exports.
- The agreement allows European importers to deduct the Israeli tax from CBAM obligations.
- Israeli companies must prove a direct link between fuel tax paid and production emissions.
- The EU's CBAM mechanism initially covers cement, electricity, fertilizers, steel, aluminum, and hydrogen.
- Israel's tax is estimated to cover only 30% of actual emission costs by 2030.
- OECD reports Israel's tax is significantly lower than international benchmarks.
The European Union has agreed to recognize Israel's excise tax on polluting fuels as a carbon tax, a decision that will prevent double taxation on Israeli exports. The agreement, reached this week after extensive negotiations between Israel's Ministry of Finance, the Foreign Trade Administration, and the EU, is a significant step for Israeli exporters facing the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).
CBAM, which began collecting fees this year, requires importers to pay for emissions associated with goods from countries without a carbon tax. Initially, it covers cement, electricity, fertilizers, iron, steel, aluminum, and hydrogen. In Israel, this primarily impacts fertilizer producers, but the Ministry of Environmental Protection warns that the EU plans to expand CBAM to other energy-intensive sectors, potentially affecting plastics produced by oil refineries.
Under the new recognition, European importers will be able to deduct the Israeli tax from their CBAM obligations. However, this is contingent on proving a direct link between the fuel tax paid and the emissions generated during the production of a specific good. The differing calculation methods, Israel's tax based on fuel volume versus the EU's emission-based approach per product, will necessitate detailed documentation and calculations from Israeli companies, particularly for complex products like cement and fertilizers that include indirect emissions from electricity consumption.
Questions remain regarding how taxes paid by power plants will be verified, with a potential default price set by the European Commission as an alternative. The Ministry of Finance confirmed that state grants provided to industries for adapting to the tax will be excluded from the deductible amount. This aid program is scheduled to conclude at the end of 2030.
Despite this progress, the Israeli tax does not fully reflect the cost of emissions. The Ministry of Environmental Protection estimates that even by 2030, the natural gas tax will only cover 30% of its external costs. A report last year by the OECD highlighted that Israel's projected tax of 18 euros per ton of CO2 by 2030 falls short of the OECD's benchmark of 60 euros per ton, potentially leading to overinvestment in gas power plants at the expense of renewable energy and carbon capture technologies.