Nvidia's Impact on Israel's Economy, Housing Market Puzzles
Translated & summarized from NEWSru Israel by baba
Nvidia's significant impact on Israel's GDP growth and tax revenue is under scrutiny following the departure of its CEO, Jensen Huang, raising concerns about future investments. While the company's financials remain strong, Israeli authorities warn that its "overseas production" inflates GDP figures and distorts the real economic picture. Meanwhile, inflation surprised analysts with a drop in October, largely due to falling airfare prices, and housing purchase prices continue to decline, while rental costs surge.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Nvidia's departure of CEO Jensen Huang sparks concern over its multi-billion shekel expansion plans in Israel.
- Nvidia's Israeli operations contributed $32.3 billion to revenue in the first half of the fiscal year.
- Nvidia's tax payments to Israel reached $1.29 billion in the last fiscal year, expected to double.
- Israeli GDP growth is significantly inflated by Nvidia's "overseas production," distorting economic indicators.
- October inflation fell unexpectedly to 1.1%, driven by a 10.4% drop in airfare prices.
- Housing purchase prices in Israel have declined 1.5% nationally, while rental prices are rising rapidly.
Nvidia's significant influence on Israel's macroeconomic indicators has become a major talking point, surpassing even Intel's past impact. The recent departure of co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang, following reports of extramarital affairs, has raised concerns in Jerusalem about the tech giant's future in Israel and its planned campus expansion in Kiryat Tivon. This expansion, announced last December, involved a multi-billion shekel investment and the creation of over 10,000 jobs. While Nvidia assures continued operations, the new leadership will decide the fate of these investments, for which Israel might become just one of many development centers rather than a "second home" as Huang described it. The article draws a parallel to Intel's abandoned $25 billion factory project in Kiryat Gat, highlighting the potential for large-scale investments to be frozen or canceled.
Despite the leadership change, Nvidia's latest financial report, released November 17, showed a more than doubling of quarterly revenue to $115.8 billion, with a forecast of around $130 billion for the next quarter. The Israeli division's network operations contributed significantly, generating $32.3 billion in the first half of the fiscal year. Nvidia's tax payments to Israel were substantial, reaching $1.29 billion in the fiscal year ending January, a figure expected to double this year. Recent data from the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) indicates that Nvidia accounts for at least half of Israel's GDP growth, with the economy growing 8% year-on-year in Q3, or 6.7% compared to the previous year, largely due to "overseas production" of goods developed in Israel but manufactured and sold abroad.
However, the Ministry of Finance and the Bank of Israel caution that this growth distorts the true state of Israeli industry and the labor market. They argue that "overseas production" does not utilize Israeli capital or labor, with profits going to foreign shareholders. The Bank of Israel recommends focusing on GDP excluding this component for inflation, employment, and wage forecasts, noting that including Nvidia can be misleading regarding debt reduction. The situation is compared to Ireland's "leprechaun economy" in 2015, where GDP saw a significant artificial increase due to multinational corporations shifting intellectual property.
In other economic news, Israeli analysts were again surprised by lower-than-expected inflation in October, with the consumer price index falling 0.1% and annual inflation dropping to 1.1%. A primary driver was a 10.4% decrease in airfare prices, a recurring surprise for economists due to a change in the CBS's airfare calculation method in September 2023. This method now collects prices automatically from the internet and attributes them to the month of departure, causing significant index fluctuations during seasonal transitions.
Despite these fluctuations, food prices saw their first decrease in a long time, down 0.3%, while housing purchase prices have declined nationwide by an average of 1.5% over the past year, with the exception of Haifa. Developers are employing creative financing schemes to attract buyers, with the share of sales using preferential developer financing increasing to 30%. However, this price drop is confined to the purchase market, as rental prices continue to rise significantly faster than inflation, increasing by 5.5% for new tenants and 2.8% for lease renewals. This surge in rental costs, coupled with economic uncertainty and expectations of further purchase price drops, is causing many families to postpone buying homes. The Ministry of Construction and Housing acknowledges its inability to solve the rising rental prices, noting a lack of comprehensive data on the rental market, which has an estimated annual turnover of 50 billion shekels.
Mentioned
