Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

HaaretzSecurity

Kibbutz Gaza Families Clash Over Preserving Oct. 7 Massacre Site

Translated & summarized from Haaretz by baba

Center-leftNeutral tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

Families of victims of the October 7th massacre at Kibbutz Kfar Aza's "Young Generation" neighborhood are in a legal and public dispute over the preservation of the site. While the kibbutz voted to demolish most structures and relocate some to a memorial, victims' families are petitioning the High Court to preserve the homes as national heritage. They argue the buildings are crucial evidence of the massacre, while some kibbutz members prioritize rebuilding and living in the community, separate from the trauma.

The kibbutz plans a large commemoration area at its entrance, aiming to balance remembrance with the community's rehabilitation. The High Court is now involved in mediating the conflict between the desire to rebuild and the demand to preserve the massacre site as a historical testament.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Victims' families are petitioning Israel's High Court to preserve the "Young Generation" neighborhood in Kibbutz Kfar Aza as a national heritage site.
  • Kibbutz Kfar Aza members voted to demolish most of the "Young Generation" neighborhood and relocate selected structures to a memorial.
  • 11 residents were killed and 7 abducted in the "Young Generation" neighborhood during the October 7th Hamas attack.
  • The state supports the kibbutz's right to decide on commemoration but acknowledges professional preference for preserving structures in situ.
  • The dispute highlights a broader conflict in Gaza border communities between rebuilding and preserving massacre sites.
  • Anat Elkabetz, a mother of a victim, is leading efforts to preserve the neighborhood as crucial historical evidence.

Kibbutz Kfar Aza is undergoing reconstruction after the October 7th massacre, with about 60 families already residing there and half of its members planning to return. However, the "Young Generation" neighborhood, a focal point of the attack where 11 of its 37 residents were killed and seven abducted, remains largely as it was on the day of the massacre. This area, dubbed the "Ground Zero" of Kfar Aza, has become a site of pilgrimage for visitors. Ahead of residents' return, the neighborhood was fenced off, and a green barrier was erected to shield it from the revitalized kibbutz.

In March, kibbutz members voted on a plan to demolish the neighborhood, relocate selected structures to a memorial complex, and establish a memorial park on the original site. This plan, supported by 69% of voters, has ignited controversy. Some residents advocate for removing the burnt houses to aid their recovery, while families of the murdered insist on preserving the buildings as physical evidence of the massacre.

Nine families of the neighborhood's victims petitioned the High Court of Justice (Bagatz) in May, demanding the preservation of the "Young Generation" homes and recognition of the area as a national heritage site. They argue the kibbutz's demolition and relocation decision was flawed, lacking sufficient professional review and neglecting the voices of bereaved families and abductees. The petitioners contend the buildings are national evidence, not solely kibbutz property, and their destruction or relocation would cause irreparable harm.

The state, in its July response, supported the kibbutz's decision and residents' right to determine their commemoration methods. However, it acknowledged the professional preference for preserving structures in their original location, while balancing this with the needs of rehabilitation and return to kibbutz life.

Anat Elkabetz, whose daughter Sivan and her fiancé Naor Hassidim were murdered in the neighborhood, is among the petitioners and plans to return to the kibbutz. She views the buildings not as a memorial but as crucial testimony to the events of October 7th, emphasizing their historical importance and the need for state intervention. Elkabetz proposed solutions like an access road and relocating a row of houses to separate the neighborhood from residential areas, stressing the need to preserve the entire neighborhood, including its location and the breached gate through which attackers entered.

Kibbutz Chairwoman Sigal Moran stated that the decision regarding the neighborhood impacted some families' return plans. She emphasized the kibbutz's commitment to telling the story of the massacre globally through a large commemoration area at the kibbutz entrance, aiming for a balance between life and remembrance. Ilana Tzuk, a kibbutz management member who returned in July, affirmed that the decisions were made democratically and represent the community's desire to live, rehabilitate, and actively participate in preserving their story, but separate from their private living spaces.

Amir Zini, whose son Niral and his girlfriend were murdered in the neighborhood, opposes relocation, stating that traumas should not be erased but confronted. He compares the situation to Germany and Poland, where sites of atrocities were left for future generations to learn from, calling the relocation plan a "joke."

HaaretzLeft · Tel Aviv

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire