Ultra-Orthodox Parties Urged to Prioritize Soldiers' Rights in Coalition Talks
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
Haredi political parties are urged to prioritize the needs of Haredi soldiers in upcoming coalition negotiations, as both political blocs seek their support. The article highlights challenges faced by Haredi soldiers regarding religious observance and identity within the IDF. It calls for concrete demands in coalition agreements to ensure better conditions, dedicated facilities, and more Haredi-specific service tracks.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Haredi parties must demand better conditions for serving soldiers in coalition talks.
- Haredi soldiers face religious observance challenges like kashrut and Shabbat in the IDF.
- The focus on conscription exemptions neglects the needs of soldiers already serving.
- Past punitive measures have failed to increase Haredi combat enlistment.
- Demands should include expanded religious accommodations and dedicated Haredi service tracks.
Following recent elections, ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) parties are in a strong political position, with both the current government bloc and the opposition vying for their support. A central issue in coalition negotiations is expected to be the military conscription law. The article argues that Haredi parties must leverage this opportunity to secure better conditions for Haredi soldiers already serving in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF).
Many Haredi soldiers reportedly face challenges related to kashrut, Shabbat observance, modesty, gender separation, and Torah study while in service, often feeling like outsiders rather than integral members of the military. While the IDF has established units like the Haredi "Hasmonean" brigade, the article points out that not all Haredi soldiers are combat-oriented, with many serving in technological, administrative, and support roles. It questions why these soldiers would receive less support than their combat counterparts, as their Haredi identity remains constant regardless of their role.
The piece criticizes the current focus on who is exempt from service, arguing that the needs of those already serving are neglected. It suggests that past punitive measures aimed at increasing Haredi enlistment have failed to boost combat recruitment and have instead deepened divisions with the religious Zionist community.
Therefore, the article urges Haredi political leaders to make concrete demands in coalition agreements. These demands should include expanding IDF directives to ensure all Haredi soldiers receive full accommodations for their religious lifestyle, establishing a dedicated Haredi military campus for non-combat roles, and creating more exclusively Haredi service tracks. These are presented not as privileges but as essential conditions for Haredi soldiers to serve without compromising their identity.
The author contends that failing to address the needs of Haredi soldiers in coalition deals would be a significant oversight, especially when political capital is being used to negotiate exemptions for non-conscripts. It concludes that any agreement on conscription that neglects the rights of currently serving Haredi soldiers would be incomplete.