Italian Jewish Politician Resigns in Tears Over Anti-Antisemitism Law Vote
Translated & summarized from Israel Hayom by baba
Italian Jewish politician Emanuele Fiano resigned from the Democratic Party on Wednesday after it voted against a new law adopting the IHRA definition of antisemitism. The law, passed by parliament, aims to combat antisemitism but the PD argued it could stifle criticism of Israel. Fiano, a former leader of Milan's Jewish community, called the vote a "red line." While Jewish community leaders welcomed the law, Fiano and others expressed concern over the party's opposition and the divisive parliamentary vote.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Jewish politician Emanuele Fiano resigned from Italy's Democratic Party over its vote against an antisemitism law.
- The new law adopts the IHRA definition of antisemitism, which the PD fears could silence criticism of Israel.
- Fiano, a Holocaust survivor's son, called the party's vote a "red line" and resigned tearfully.
- The Democratic Party's stance shifted from abstention in the Senate to voting against the bill in the Chamber of Deputies.
- Italian Jewish leaders welcomed the law, but expressed concern over the lack of unanimous parliamentary support.
- Public opinion in Italy is largely unfavorable towards Israel, according to a recent Pew Research poll.
Emanuele Fiano, a 63-year-old Jewish politician in Italy's Democratic Party (PD), tearfully resigned from his party on Wednesday after it voted against a new law aimed at combating antisemitism. The legislation, which passed parliament on Tuesday evening with a 147-93 majority, formally adopts the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism into Italian law. The PD, the largest opposition party, argued that the IHRA definition could be used to silence criticism of Israel. Fiano, who served 16 years in the Italian parliament and previously led Milan's Jewish community, stated that his party's vote crossed a "red line." He learned of the party's intention to vote against the bill while visiting Auschwitz, a detail that deeply affected him as his father was a Holocaust survivor. He described a call from PD Chairwoman Elly Schlein, who is of Jewish heritage, attempting to dissuade him, but Fiano remained resolute in his decision to leave.
The PD's stance on the bill evolved during the legislative process; the party abstained in the Senate in March but voted against it in the Chamber of Deputies. Fiano pointed out that the Italian government had already adopted the IHRA definition in 2020 when the PD was part of the ruling coalition. His organization, "Left for Israel," which supports a two-state solution, had published a petition urging the center-left not to oppose the bill, warning it would create a "painful and deep rift with Italian Jewry." The petition also referenced a call by Senator Liliana Segre, a Holocaust survivor, for a consensus-based text.
The new law officially incorporates the IHRA definition, developed in 2016, into Italian legislation for the first time. Italian media report it also establishes a national coordinator for combating antisemitism within the Prime Minister's office, mandates a three-year national plan, and creates a database for tracking antisemitic incidents, though it does not include criminal penalties. The IHRA definition includes examples related to Israel, such as denying the Jewish people's right to self-determination, applying a double standard to Israel, and comparing its policies to those of the Nazis, while also emphasizing that criticism of Israel, like any other country, is not antisemitic.
Opposition parties, including Angelo Bonelli of the Greens and Left Alliance, accused the right-wing government of using the antisemitism law to stifle criticism. However, coalition members like Paolo Emilio Russo of Forza Italia insisted that political criticism of Israel would remain protected and that freedom of expression would not be limited. A small faction within the PD abstained from the vote, defying the party leadership's directive to vote against the bill. The law's passage occurs amidst a backdrop of increasingly negative public opinion towards Israel in Italy, with a Pew Research Center poll in June showing 75% of Italians holding unfavorable views. Leaders of Italian Jewish organizations, including Livia Ottolenghi of the Union of Italian Jewish Communities and Victor Fadlun of the Jewish Community of Rome, welcomed the law's approval, calling it a strengthening of democratic antibodies and a significant achievement. However, they also expressed concern about the infiltration of hate speech into political movements and noted that the lack of a unanimous parliamentary vote was a "very bad sign."
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Centre 2Right 1
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.