Ex-Shin Bet Official Criticizes Leadership, Cites Leaks
Translated & summarized from Cursorinfo by baba
Former Shin Bet official Ilan Lotan criticized the agency's leadership, citing inexperienced public statements by Shin Bet chief David Zini regarding alleged vote buying and unprecedented information leaks. Lotan's remarks followed the Central Elections Committee's announcement that no evidence of vote buying impacting election results was found. Lotan supports Knesset committee head Avigdor Lieberman's plan to investigate the security agencies' decision-making processes.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Former Shin Bet official Ilan Lotan criticized current leadership and alleged information leaks.
- Shin Bet chief David Zini's statements on vote buying were called "inexperienced" by Lotan.
- Central Elections Committee found no evidence of vote buying affecting election results.
- Lotan expressed concern over unprecedented leaks of information from the Shin Bet.
- Avigdor Lieberman plans to summon security agency heads for investigation.
- Lotan highlighted Shin Bet values of state-oriented approach and questioning everything.
A former high-ranking Shin Bet official, Ilan Lotan, has voiced concerns over the internal workings of the security agency, criticizing its leadership's recent public statements and alleged information leaks. Lotan suggested that the Shin Bet chief, David Zini, made inexperienced public remarks about alleged vote buying during elections, especially after the Chairman of the Central Elections Committee, Judge Noam Solberg, announced that no evidence of vote buying impacting election results had been found. Lotan, speaking on radio 103FM, stated that such sensitive information is usually verified multiple times before public release, attributing Zini's statements to "inexperience."
Lotan also expressed alarm over what he described as unprecedented leaks of information from the Shin Bet to the press, noting that journalists were previously off-limits. He stated that information is now "leaking like through a sieve" and that he does not recall such a phenomenon. He believes something "not good" is happening within the organization, though he is unsure if it is directly related to the current head of the service and senior management, but stressed that order needs to be restored.
He voiced support for Avigdor Lieberman, who recently took over the Knesset Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense. Lieberman has pledged to summon the heads of security agencies, including the Shin Bet, to investigate discrepancies and potential external considerations in decision-making. Lotan believes this process will lead to the correct decisions.
Lotan emphasized that the Shin Bet's core values include a "state-oriented approach," restraint in the use of force, and the duty to question everything. He implied that the current leadership has not adhered to these principles, particularly in light of Zini's comparison of the election issue to a "strategic terror attack" on par with October 7th.
The Shin Bet's investigation, approved by Solberg and Zini on November 17th, found no evidence of vote buying on a scale that could alter election outcomes, particularly within the Arab sector.
Mentioned