Commentator Says Knesset Speaker Change Reflects 'Second Israel' Theory
Translated & summarized from Srugim by baba
Commentator Avishai Ben-Chaim criticized the appointment of Matan Kahana as Knesset Speaker, replacing Amir Ohana, calling it a symbolic act driven by the "Second Israel" theory. He claims a coalition of elites and Arab parties removed the Mizrahi Ohana to install Kahana, aiming to reverse the integration of Mizrahim into Israeli society. Ben-Chaim also noted a predicted link between post-Zionism and anti-Mizrahi sentiment.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Commentator Avishai Ben-Chaim decried Matan Kahana's appointment as Knesset Speaker over Amir Ohana.
- Ben-Chaim stated the change reflects the "Second Israel" theory shaping Israeli history.
- He claimed elites and Arab parties united to remove Mizrahi speaker Amir Ohana.
- The "Second Israel" theory predicts a shift away from traditional left-right politics.
- Ben-Chaim noted a correlation between post-Zionism and anti-Mizrahi sentiment.
Israeli commentator Avishai Ben-Chaim expressed dismay Wednesday over the appointment of Matan Kahana as the new Knesset Speaker, replacing Amir Ohana. Ben-Chaim described the move as symbolic and a manifestation of the "Second Israel" theory, which he believes is shaping Israeli history.
He argued that a coalition of the religious Zionist elite, wealthy left-wing elites, and the Arab parties Ra'am and Hadash united to remove Ohana, a Mizrahi (Eastern heritage) Jew, and install Kahana, who he characterized as part of the religious Zionist elite. Ben-Chaim stated this development, which he finds deeply painful, was predicted by the "Second Israel" theory years ago.
According to Ben-Chaim, the theory posited the creation of a new political structure where traditional left-right divides would diminish. He elaborated that certain figures from the religious Zionist elite, like Kahana, would shift allegiance to "First Israel" and aid the left's agenda to suppress the 1977 "revolution" that brought Mizrahim into the Israeli mainstream, thereby restoring them to their former social standing.
Ben-Chaim also highlighted another painful aspect of the "Second Israel" theory, which he noted was once dismissed as far-fetched: a correlation between post-Zionism and anti-Mizrahi sentiment. The article also briefly mentions a former Mossad official's comment that Netanyahu made a serious mistake regarding an unnamed individual.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Right 1
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.