Channel 14 Ordered to Pay Professor NIS 40,000 for Defamation
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
Israel's Central District Court has ordered Channel 14 to pay Professor Shlomo Moran NIS 20,000 in damages and NIS 20,000 in legal costs for defamation. The ruling stems from a May 2023 article that falsely claimed Moran incorporated his political writings into his university course materials. The court found this specific accusation to be damaging and distinct from other criticisms leveled against the professor.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Channel 14 must pay Professor Shlomo Moran NIS 20,000 for defamation and NIS 20,000 in legal costs.
- The court ordered the removal of defamatory content from Channel 14's website within 14 days.
- The defamation claim centered on an article alleging Professor Moran used his political writings in course materials.
- The Central District Court overturned a lower court's dismissal of Moran's lawsuit.
- The court stressed the difference between public political expression and academic requirements.
Israel's Central District Court ruled last Friday that Channel 14 defamed Professor Shlomo Moran, ordering the media outlet to pay him NIS 20,000 in damages and an equal amount for legal expenses. The court also mandated the removal of the defamatory content from the channel's website within 14 days.
The case originated in May 2023 with an article published on Channel 14's website by Avital Fried, titled "Antisemitism Under the Auspices of Academia: Technion Lecturer Compares Nazism to Religious Zionism." The article, based on a complaint by the Im Tirtzu organization, accused Moran, a Professor Emeritus of Computer Science at the Technion, of using faculty resources to promote his political views and posting articles critical of religious Zionism on his office door and faculty webpage.
A key point of contention was the claim that Moran incorporated his own political articles into his course materials. While a lower court had dismissed Moran's NIS 140,000 lawsuit, ruling that the claim about course materials was not proven and that Channel 14 itself admitted it was inaccurate, the district court overturned this decision on appeal.
Judge Dror Arad-Elon emphasized the significant difference between displaying political views publicly and forcing students to engage with them as academic material. He stated that including political articles in a computer science course violates academic standards and could uniquely harm Moran's reputation. The judge rejected Channel 14's argument that the distinction between publishing articles "as part of" course materials versus "and part of" them was negligible, noting that "sometimes one letter or one word is enough to change the meaning of an expression."
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Haredi 1Other 1
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.