Ultra-Orthodox Rabbis Reject Draft Exemption Plan, Hinder Government Formation
Translated & summarized from Srugim by baba
Ultra-Orthodox rabbis from United Torah Judaism are rejecting proposed draft exemption plans from the "change bloc" led by Gadi Eisenkot. Rabbi Dov Lando opposes any limits on the number of Torah students, a stance that could prevent his party from joining a "change government." Negotiations are reportedly stalled, with difficulty finding a compromise acceptable to all parties involved.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Haredi rabbis reject draft exemption plans from the "change bloc" led by Gadi Eisenkot.
- Rabbi Dov Lando opposes any law limiting the number of Torah students.
- The Haredi opposition could prevent United Torah Judaism from joining a "change government."
- Negotiations are stalled, with difficulty finding a compromise acceptable to all.
- Rabbi Lando favors laws based on previous Knesset discussions or the 2018 Lieberman Law.
Ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) rabbis from the United Torah Judaism party have rejected proposed frameworks for military conscription and exemptions for Torah scholars, according to reports published Tuesday. The opposition centers on a plan promoted by the "change bloc," led by Gadi Eisenkot, which reportedly offers exemptions to 3% of the annual conscription cohort to continue their studies under the "Torah is their occupation" principle. The remaining conscripts would be required to perform national or civil service.
Rabbi Dov Lando, a prominent Haredi leader, has stated he will not agree to any law that limits the number of Torah students. His position is that anyone wishing to study Torah should be allowed to do so without numerical restrictions. However, Rabbi Lando is reportedly open to a law that includes conscription targets and sanctions, similar to proposals discussed by MKs Yuli Edelstein and Boaz Bismuth, provided it permits unlimited Torah study.
This opposition from Rabbi Lando is seen as a critical obstacle to United Torah Judaism joining a potential "change government." Reporter Yishai Cohen indicated that Rabbi Lando's stance will largely determine whether such a government can be formed with the party's participation. Cohen expressed difficulty in finding a compromise that would satisfy Rabbi Lando, Eisenkot, and former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett.
Rabbi Lando's preferred approach involves a law based on frameworks discussed in the previous Knesset or on the Lieberman Law from 2018. Another report by Amit Segal indicated that Rabbi Hirsch also rejects the change bloc's exemption plan, leaving the negotiations with the Haredi parties stalled.
Mentioned