Rabbi Argues Jewish Settlement in Jericho Permitted Despite Ancient Curse
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Rabbi Moshe Harari has stated that Jewish settlement in Jericho is permitted, despite an ancient curse by Joshua bin Nun on those who rebuild the city. He presented four halachic arguments, including that the city was rebuilt after the curse, the curse applied to walls not the city, it targeted individuals not communities, and the exact location is uncertain. Rabbi Harari concluded that settling in Jericho today is a great mitzvah.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Rabbi Moshe Harari stated Jewish settlement in Jericho is permissible despite an ancient curse.
- The curse, by Joshua bin Nun, warned of sons dying during the city's rebuilding.
- Rabbi Harari cited four halachic arguments permitting settlement in Jericho.
- He noted Jewish settlement existed in Jericho during ancient periods after the curse.
- Rabbi Harari concluded settling in Jericho today is a great mitzvah.
Rabbi Moshe Harari has asserted that Jewish settlement in Jericho is permissible, addressing concerns stemming from an ancient curse placed on the city's rebuilders. The curse, attributed to Joshua bin Nun and detailed in the Book of Joshua, stipulated that anyone rebuilding Jericho would lose his sons during the construction.
Rabbi Harari presented four main halachic (Jewish legal) arguments to permit new settlement in Jericho, citing biblical, Talmudic, and rabbinic sources. He noted that despite the curse, Jewish settlement in Jericho existed during the First and Second Temple periods and even after the destruction of the Second Temple.
The first argument posits that since the city was rebuilt after Joshua's time, subsequent rebuilding is permitted even if the city was destroyed again. The second argument suggests the curse specifically targeted the rebuilding of the city's walls, which fell miraculously during Joshua's conquest, not the city itself. The third argument distinguishes between an individual and a community, stating the curse's wording "cursed is the man" implies it applies only to a private individual, not a collective or someone acting on behalf of a community.
The fourth argument questions the precise location of the ancient Jericho to which the curse applied, noting that some sources permit building in the area known as "the lowlands of Jericho." Rabbi Harari concluded that these arguments, among others, allow for settlement in Jericho today, stating it is a great mitzvah (commandment) to settle there.
He referenced several works that delve into the halachic discussion, including "Margaliot Hayam," "Eretz Hemda," Responsa "Tzitz Eliezer," "Hadar Hanevi'im," and "Tiferet Yericho."
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.