Right-Wing Activist to Appeal Defamation Ruling Ordering Him to Pay Over 115,000 Shekels
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
Right-wing activist Ran Karmi Buzaglo will appeal a court decision ordering him to pay former IDF Spokesperson Avi Benayahu over 115,000 shekels in damages and legal fees. The defamation lawsuit stemmed from social media posts accusing Benayahu of responsibility for soldiers' extradition and calling him "filth." Buzaglo claimed the posts were sarcastic and protected by free speech, but the court rejected this, ruling his actions could harm public discourse. Buzaglo vowed to "fight back" as he prepares his appeal.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Ran Karmi Buzaglo will appeal a ruling ordering him to pay Avi Benayahu 115,981 shekels.
- The defamation case involved social media posts accusing Benayahu of soldier extradition responsibility.
- Buzaglo claimed his posts were sarcastic responses protected by free speech.
- The court rejected the free speech defense, citing potential harm to public discourse.
- Buzaglo vowed to "fight back" and continue his public stance.
Right-wing activist Ran Karmi Buzaglo announced Tuesday he will appeal a court ruling that ordered him to pay former IDF Spokesperson Avi Benayahu 115,981 shekels. The original ruling was issued on October 21, 2026, by the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court, which found Buzaglo liable for defamation. Judge Aviam Barkai ordered Buzaglo to pay Benayahu 80,000 shekels in damages, plus 23,600 shekels for legal costs and interest.
The lawsuit centered on three social media posts made by Buzaglo, in which he accused Benayahu of being responsible for the extradition of IDF soldiers for investigation in Brazil. In one post, Buzaglo referred to Benayahu as "filth." Benayahu testified that he had demanded an apology from Buzaglo after the posts, and when Buzaglo refused, the defamation suit was filed.
Buzaglo had argued in court that the lawsuit was an attempt to silence him and infringe upon freedom of speech. Judge Barkai rejected this claim, stating that the criteria for a "strategic lawsuit against public participation" (SLAPP) were not met. The judge cited a Supreme Court ruling, noting that Buzaglo's series of posts could actually harm public discourse, potentially causing others to self-censor for fear of becoming targets.
As Buzaglo prepares his appeal, he claims one of the posts was a humorous and sarcastic response to a January 2025 post by Benayahu. In that post, Benayahu shared a photo of a soldier at a soccer game, questioning military oversight. Buzaglo stated, "I have never given up on the battlefield and have no intention of changing my ways. I am determined to fight back." His lawyer, Yael Tuthan, argued that the ruling restricts freedom of expression and satire in public debate, comparing it to sharp satirical posts made by left-wing figures against right-wing politicians that do not result in such judgments.