Parents Sue Doctor for $370,000 After Daughter Loses Hearing
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
The parents of a 13-year-old girl are suing an ENT doctor for approximately $370,000, alleging negligence caused her hearing loss. They claim the doctor failed to order necessary scans and refer her to specialists, leading to irreversible damage. The lawsuit details the girl's medical history, the alleged failures in her treatment, and the resulting disabilities and expenses. Clalit Health Services stated they have not yet received the claim and will respond in court.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Parents are suing an ENT doctor for $370,000 over alleged negligence causing their daughter's hearing loss.
- The lawsuit claims the doctor failed to order crucial CT/MRI scans and refer the child to specialists.
- The girl underwent surgery for a cyst, but her hearing was already destroyed, requiring a prosthesis.
- Medical reports indicate significant disabilities and a risk of further hearing deterioration.
- The parents are seeking damages for medical expenses, pain and suffering, and punitive damages.
The parents of a 13-year-old girl are suing an ear, nose, and throat doctor for approximately 1.42 million shekels (about $370,000 USD) in damages, alleging medical negligence led to their daughter's hearing loss. According to the lawsuit, the girl underwent ear surgery at age 4, but her hearing did not improve. Over the next two years, she was examined by the defendant doctor at least five times. The parents claim the doctor repeatedly recommended only continued observation and prescribed ear drops, instead of referring the child for a CT or MRI scan, conducting a thorough medical investigation, or sending her to a specialist center for pediatric ear conditions.
After two years of ineffective treatment, the parents independently took their daughter to a specialist at Shaare Zedek Medical Center. This specialist immediately ordered CT and MRI scans, which confirmed a cyst in her ear. She underwent surgery to remove the cyst, but it was discovered during the procedure that the condition had already destroyed her hearing. Doctors were then forced to implant an artificial prosthesis in her ear.
Medical reports attached to the lawsuit indicate the girl suffers from significant disabilities. An ENT expert also pointed to a risk of further hearing deterioration, potentially leading to complete deafness, and a high probability of future surgeries. The lawsuit states the hearing loss impairs her ability to understand speech, makes it difficult to participate in conversations and group games, and necessitates a tailored educational program with a support teacher. A speech therapist's report highlighted difficulties with understanding speech in noisy environments, language functions, vocabulary, and memory.
The parents estimate their expenses to date at 150,000 shekels for treatments, surgeries, tests, and medical equipment, plus 200,000 shekels for assistance and support needed for their daughter. They also spent approximately 70,000 shekels on medical expert opinions. In addition to compensation for physical damages, pain, suffering, and expenses, the parents are seeking 1 million shekels in punitive damages, citing what they describe as "ongoing negligence that could have been prevented with simple and inexpensive tests."
Clalit Health Services responded that the statement of claim has not yet been received and a detailed response will be provided in court once it is.