Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Day 19

Netanyahu's Chief of Staff Provided Information Leading to Ra'am Activist Probe

4 developments

YnetSecurity

Election Probe Unravels: From Ra'am Activist Arrests to PMO Source

Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba

CenterCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

An investigation is underway into the events surrounding the arrest of Ra'am activists on suspicion of vote-buying during the recent elections, with information reportedly originating from the Prime Minister's Office. The probe also examines allegations of foreign interference and a dispute between the Shin Bet chief and the Attorney General over investigative methods. While initial suspicions were raised, evidence presented so far has not established systematic election fraud, and the case against the arrested activists has weakened.

The story in 5 lines · by baba

  • Information leading to Ra'am activist arrests on election day reportedly came from a former PMO employee.
  • Shin Bet chief David Zini clashed with Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara over investigating foreign influence.
  • Chairman of the Central Elections Committee Noam Sohlberg stated elections were conducted properly despite suspicions.
  • Police investigation found weak evidence against Ra'am activists, leading to their release.
  • Suspicions of foreign funding remain under investigation, but no large-scale attempt to alter results has been proven.

Three weeks after the arrest of Ra'am activists on suspicion of vote-buying on election morning, an investigation is now examining the chain of events leading to these arrests. Information originating from the Prime Minister's Office, arrests that sparked political controversy, suspicions of foreign funding, and a direct confrontation between the Shin Bet chief and the Attorney General have all emerged. While the two main election controversies have since branched out, the evidence presented so far does not establish systematic damage to the integrity of the elections.

On election morning, October 27, police announced the arrest of three activists identified with Ra'am in the Negev, suspected of receiving tens of thousands of shekels in cash and Ra'am ballots. The case was transferred to Lahav 433, and four more suspects were arrested, including three school principals. Ra'am claimed the arrests were intended to suppress Arab voter turnout, while Netanyahu and the Likud echoed the police announcement, presenting the arrests as proof of an attempt to steal the election. The source of the information leading to the arrests was initially unknown.

Two days after the election, on October 29, the Chairman of the Central Elections Committee, Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg, wrote to Shin Bet Director David Zini, ordering a deeper investigation into suspected foreign interference. Reports suggested the suspicion focused on tens of millions of shekels transferred from Qatar and later Turkey. It was revealed that the Shin Bet had possessed information prior to the election but had not shared it with the committee, contradicting Zini's statement that the elections were running smoothly. Legal sources indicated the information did not establish systematic election fraud, and law enforcement estimated the case against the activists was weak, as they provided explanations for the money found.

Further revelations indicated that the information leading to the Ra'am activists' arrests came from the Prime Minister's Office, specifically from the acting head of staff, Edo Nordan, who contacted Police Commissioner Danny Levy directly. Contrary to earlier reports, fuel coupons were not found, and the police stated there was no connection between the Ra'am case and the Shin Bet's investigation into foreign interference. On November 1, a judge criticized the police's evidence and ordered the release of one suspect, while others were also released despite police requests for continued detention. One detainee explained the cash envelopes were for charity donations, not vote-buying.

Following a direct confrontation, Sohlberg, Zini, and Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara issued a joint statement asserting the elections were conducted properly and their results reflected the voters' will, even if suspicions were confirmed. The Likud disagreed, stating a "heavy cloud" still hung over the results. The Shin Bet conducted urgent discussions and operations to complete its investigation before the official results were announced. The Likud also petitioned the Central Elections Committee to convene its presidency to receive details on the suspicions before the results were published.

On November 3, it was revealed that the Shin Bet and Mossad had identified a channel for transferring money from Qatar to a political entity within the Joint List to encourage voter turnout, though the scale was not expected to alter the election outcome. Investigations also looked into whether the Palestinian Authority transferred funds to Arab parties. Zini reportedly clashed with Baharav-Miara over classifying the foreign influence probe as a security offense to enable broader investigative tools, a demand the Attorney General deemed illegal. Zini also requested to question senior figures in Arab parties, including Mansour Abbas, Ahmed Tibi, Sami Abu Shehadeh, and Ayman Odeh, though evidence was reportedly strong only against Odeh.

On November 4, the Shin Bet sent a summary to the Elections Committee, stating intelligence indicated massive funding from foreign states and entities with covert, even hostile, interests, potentially affecting thousands. Zini reportedly mentioned sums up to 100 million shekels, though the Shin Bet admitted further investigation was needed. Reports detailed Baharav-Miara's refusal to allow questioning of Knesset members without reasonable suspicion, with Zini reportedly responding, "Let me investigate, and then there will be reasonable suspicion." The head of the Police Investigations Department, Commander Boaz Balt, warned against disproportionate investigations harming democracy.

On November 5, the Shin Bet began transferring materials related to the Arab sector's polling stations to the investigation team in installments. The following day, Balt instructed officers not to transfer any election-related information to the Shin Bet without his approval. On November 10, the police submitted an opinion to the Attorney General stating that the reviewed materials did not establish suspicion of election financing or security offenses, and even the evidence against Ayman Odeh was weak. The Likud countered that the police were not adequately investigating complaints of irregularities.

Recent reports revealed that the "incriminating information" against the Ra'am activists came from Daniel (Dani) Greenberg, a former PMO employee and associate of former Director General Yossi Shelly. Greenberg allegedly provided information to a police intelligence officer, which was then entered into police systems, leading to the raids on the activists' homes without search or arrest warrants. The investigation is examining whether this information was deliberately entered to trigger arrests on election day and bolster the campaign against Arab voting. Zini's request to wiretap five Arab Knesset members on election day was reportedly blocked. He also claimed to have a large file on Arab election theft since 2018 that previous Shin Bet heads ignored.

The Prime Minister's Office denied a planned operation but confirmed that criminal information reached Nordan, who connected the source to the police, stating it was the expected action of a law-abiding citizen. They denied further involvement by the chief of staff and called other publications false. A police intelligence officer in the Southern District had initially refused to carry out the Ra'am activists' arrests, demanding to meet the source. The Police Investigations Department later instructed officers not to share election-related information with the Shin Bet without approval.

The Police Commissioner has ordered a review of the decision-making processes and police conduct during the arrests, with conclusions expected within a week. While the police maintain they acted to preserve election integrity, the Attorney General has halted the review pending clarification. The suspicions of foreign funding remain under investigation, but so far, no evidence of a large-scale attempt to alter results has been presented, as repeatedly clarified by the Attorney General and the Chairman of the Central Elections Committee. The case against the Ra'am activists has weakened, and the question of who initiated the arrests and whether information was used for political motives is being examined, alongside how law enforcement agencies exercised their authority during this sensitive democratic period.

YnetCentre · Rishon LeZion

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire