Israel's Supreme Court Orders Health Clinic for Shuafat Refugee Camp
Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba
Israel's Supreme Court has ordered the Ministry of Health and Jerusalem Municipality to establish a mother and child health clinic in the Shuafat refugee camp and surrounding neighborhoods. The ruling addresses a petition highlighting the lack of basic health services for thousands of children and pregnant women in the area. A temporary clinic must be operational by February 1, 2027, with a permanent facility to follow within three to five years. The court cited the violation of the right to health and the National Health Insurance Law, ordering the respondents to pay 30,000 shekels in legal costs.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Supreme Court orders health clinic for Shuafat refugee camp and nearby neighborhoods.
- Thousands of children and pregnant women lacked basic health services, petition stated.
- Temporary clinic required by February 1, 2027, permanent facility within 3-5 years.
- Ruling cites violation of right to health and health insurance law.
- Jerusalem Municipality and Health Ministry ordered to pay 30,000 shekels.
- Clinic establishment follows years of failed attempts and legal challenges.
Israel's Supreme Court has ordered the Ministry of Health and the Jerusalem Municipality to establish a "Tipat Halav" (mother and child health) clinic in the Shuafat refugee camp. The ruling, issued on Sunday, also mandates that the clinic serve the adjacent neighborhoods of Ras Khamis, Ras Shahada, and Dahiyat al-Salam, which fall under Jerusalem's jurisdiction but are located beyond the separation barrier. The decision stems from a petition filed in 2021 by five mothers and the Association for Civil Rights, who argued that thousands of young children and pregnant women in these areas lacked access to basic health services like vaccinations and prenatal care. Residents were forced to travel to other parts of the city, enduring lengthy waits and security checks at checkpoints.
In its ruling, Justice Dafna Barak-Erez stated that the situation constitutes an unjustified infringement on the right to health and violates the National Health Insurance Law, which requires services to be provided within a reasonable time and distance. The court noted a history of failed attempts to establish the clinic, including canceled tenders and stalled plans for a mobile unit due to security concerns. The municipality and state had opted to wait for a permanent solution rather than proceed with a mobile service.
Jerusalem Mayor Moshe Lion has emphasized his administration's focus on developing East Jerusalem and reducing disparities. His tenure has seen significant investments in infrastructure, education, and services for Arab residents, including a NIS 100 million upgrade to East Jerusalem's business center and the establishment of a community sports center. However, these efforts have not yet addressed the lack of basic health facilities in areas like Shuafat.
The permanent clinic is planned for a public building complex that the municipality expects to take three to five years to construct. Until then, the Ministry of Health and Jerusalem Municipality are required to operate a temporary clinic in a rented municipal building by February 1, 2027. If this proves unfeasible, they must operate a mobile service by that date and complete the permanent facility by July 1, 2027. The state and municipality were ordered to pay the petitioners NIS 30,000 in legal costs. Justice Barak-Erez concluded by referencing the first "Tipat Halav" clinic established in Jerusalem in 1921 by Dr. Helena Kagan, stating it was time for its legacy to extend throughout the entire city.