Israel's Secular Population Wins Saturday Shopping Battles
Translated & summarized from TheMarker by baba
A legal battle is ongoing in Israel over Saturday mall openings, with Melisron petitioning to open its Petah Tikva mall, citing the success of secular-oriented shopping centers operating on the Sabbath. This trend contrasts with a 1990s ruling that allowed a mall owner to close on Saturdays. The article suggests secular Israelis are winning the commercial fight, but the larger battles may involve public transportation on the Sabbath, as Knesset discusses a new conscription law.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Melisron has petitioned a court to open its Big mall in Petah Tikva on Saturdays.
- Secular Israelis appear to be winning the fight for Saturday commerce, with malls operating on the Sabbath.
- A 1990s Supreme Court ruling allowed a private mall owner to close on Saturdays.
- The success of "Big Fashion Galiloot" is driving competition for Saturday shoppers.
- The article suggests future battles will focus on public transportation, like trains, operating on Saturdays.
A legal battle is underway in Israel over the opening of shopping malls on Saturdays, with a recent petition by Melisron, controlled by Liora Ofer, demanding that the city of Petah Tikva allow its "Big" mall to open on the Sabbath. This follows a trend where secular Israelis appear to be winning the fight for Saturday commerce, exemplified by the successful operation of "Big Fashion Galiloot" which opened two years ago and operates on Saturdays, drawing significant crowds and altering shopping patterns in the Gush Dan region.
The current dispute highlights a shift in societal norms and business practices. Melisron's petition argues that the Big mall in Petah Tikva is located in an industrial zone, far from residential areas, and thus poses no issue for Saturday operation, especially since a cinema and other businesses nearby are already open on weekends. Melisron claims the municipality has not responded to their inquiries, possibly due to the mayor's legal troubles.
The article contrasts this with a situation nearly 30 years ago when Lev Leviev, then owner of Africa Israel, decided to close the Ramat Aviv mall on Saturdays. This decision sparked secular protests and threats of consumer boycotts, leading Leviev to appeal to the Supreme Court. Then-President Aharon Barak ruled in Leviev's favor, recognizing a private business owner's right to determine their property's rest days. Despite initial fears, the Ramat Aviv mall became highly successful, and residents eventually appreciated the Saturday quiet.
However, Africa Israel later collapsed, and the Ramat Aviv mall was sold to Melisron, which began opening some food and cafe sections on Saturdays. The current push to open malls on Saturdays is seen as a response to the success of "Big Fashion Galiloot" and the impending opening of a competing Big mall in Petah Tikva in 2028, just 400 meters away. Melisron fears being at a disadvantage if they remain closed on Saturdays while their competitor operates.
This comes as the Knesset begins discussions on a new conscription law and aims to rebuild relations with the Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties, who the article implies are willing to concede on commercial matters in exchange for concessions on military conscription and state funding.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
