Israeli Courts Raise Costs for Plaintiffs in Class Action Lawsuits
Translated & summarized from Globes by baba
An Israeli court ordered a plaintiff's lawyer to pay 50,000 shekels in legal costs after dismissing his class action lawsuit against KSP for alleged spam. The ruling is part of a trend to increase costs for frivolous claims, following a Supreme Court directive. The plaintiff's lawyer, Amit Zilberg, intends to appeal, calling the cost award excessive and a deterrent to accessing justice. KSP incurred 344,000 shekels in defense costs for the case.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- An Israeli court ordered lawyer Amit Zilberg to pay 50,000 shekels in costs after dismissing his class action suit against KSP.
- The ruling reflects a trend of higher costs for frivolous class action claims, influenced by a Supreme Court decision.
- KSP incurred 344,000 shekels in defense costs, while the plaintiff was ordered to pay 50,000 shekels.
- The lawsuit alleged KSP sent unsolicited marketing emails, but the court found it was a minor, isolated error.
- The plaintiff's lawyer plans to appeal, citing legal errors and a dangerous precedent for accessing justice.
The Tel Aviv District Court has dismissed a class action lawsuit against KSP, a retail chain for computers and mobile products, ordering the plaintiff, attorney Amit Zilberg, to pay 50,000 shekels in legal costs. Zilberg, known for filing numerous spam-related lawsuits, heads an anti-spam organization. This ruling reflects a broader trend, influenced by an April Supreme Court decision, to impose higher costs on those filing frivolous claims, aiming to deter such actions. While 50,000 shekels is considered a significant sum for a class action plaintiff, it is part of a judicial move to increase these fees to discourage unnecessary litigation.
Despite the trend of increasing costs, KSP incurred substantial expenses of 344,000 shekels in defending the case. In a notable prior instance last October, a court awarded 100,000 shekels in costs against a plaintiff whose lawsuits were deemed strategic and motivated by ulterior motives rather than serving the public interest. Judge Rachel Erkovich, who presided over the KSP case, also recently ordered 40,000 shekels in costs against a plaintiff who withdrew a lawsuit against a tech company without prior contact or establishing factual damage.
The lawsuit against KSP, filed four years ago, alleged that the company sent unsolicited marketing emails to customers who had opted out of receiving such communications, violating the Communications Law. Zilberg and co-counsel Ziv Glasberg argued that these emails caused significant distress. The court, however, found that Zilberg failed to prove he had opted out, while KSP presented records indicating his consent. Judge Erkovich noted that while Glasberg did prove he had not consented to the specific email, it was deemed a minor error not warranting a class action. The court concluded that KSP's actions stemmed from a human error in a specific instance, not a deliberate spam policy, and that the Spam Law is not intended to penalize companies for such isolated incidents.
While the court rejected the claim that Zilberg and Glasberg were "serial litigators" driven by financial gain, it acknowledged their experience in anti-spam advocacy necessitates careful vetting of class action filings. Nati Agmon, representing KSP, welcomed the ruling, stating it aligns with a trend to curb the misuse of class action proceedings for minor issues. Conversely, Zilberg criticized the verdict, citing legal and evidentiary errors and stating his intention to appeal, arguing the high cost award deters citizens from seeking legal recourse against corporations hiding behind technical glitches.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.