Fish Import Tariff Cuts Fail to Lower Consumer Prices in Israel
Translated & summarized from Davar by baba
Israel's import tariff cuts on fresh fish, including sea bream, have failed to lower consumer prices, with sea bream prices rising by 39% despite the tariff being eliminated. The reform, intended to increase competition and savings, has instead seen importers and retailers increase their margins. Experts argue that tariff reduction alone is insufficient and advocate for policies supporting domestic production to ensure price stability and food security.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Sea bream prices in Israel rose 39% despite import tariff cuts, with the tariff fully canceled by January 2025.
- The combined margin for fish importers and retailers increased by approximately 15% during the tariff reduction period.
- A 2022 import reform aimed at lowering fish prices has not yielded expected consumer savings.
- The state lost an estimated 41 million shekels in potential tariff revenue from sea bream imports in 2023-2024.
- Experts suggest boosting local fish production is a more effective strategy than tariff reductions for consumer price relief.
Despite the reduction and eventual cancellation of import tariffs on fresh fish, intended to lower prices for consumers, the cost of popular fish like sea bream (dennis) has actually increased. Data from the Central Bureau of Statistics, processed by the Ministry of Agriculture, reveals that the price of sea bream for consumers rose by approximately 39% between 2020 and 2024, even as the import tariff was gradually reduced to zero by January 2025. Concurrently, the combined margin for importers and retailers grew by about 15%.
The import reform, initiated by former Finance Minister Avigdor Lieberman and finalized in September 2022, aimed to boost competition by progressively lowering tariffs on staple and premium fish. However, professional staff at the Ministry of Agriculture had expressed reservations, and the promised significant savings for consumers have not materialized, particularly for high-quality fish like sea bream and sea bass.
Analysis shows that the price of sea bream for consumers increased by about 13% when comparing the average of 2020-2021 to 2023-2024. The combined margin for importers and retailers expanded from 32.3 shekels per kilogram to 37.1 shekels, an increase of 4.8 shekels, or approximately 15%. While the tariff reduction offset the increase in the fish's price at the port, this stability was not passed on to consumers. Monthly price data indicates a continued upward trend, with sea bream prices reaching 70 shekels per kilogram in some months of 2024 and between 74-84 shekels in early 2025, even after the tariff was fully abolished.
Chen Flor, CEO of the Fish Breeders Association of Israel, stated that the tariff reduction is not the correct tool for lowering consumer prices, citing the sea bream's consistent price increase as clear evidence. He also pointed to significant leniencies granted to importers, including reduced quality checks and extended shelf life for fish sold as fresh, which have not translated into lower prices. The state has also forgone an estimated 41 million shekels in potential tariff revenue from sea bream imports in 2023-2024, while consumer prices rose.
Experts suggest that instead of solely relying on tariff reductions, the state could have allocated resources to encourage domestic fish production, potentially using funds from forgone tariff revenue to subsidize the establishment of advanced aquaculture systems. Such a policy, coupled with long-term strategies for research, development, infrastructure, and streamlined licensing, could increase local supply, enhance competition, and strengthen food security, ensuring that import cost savings reach consumers.