Private Brands Not Always Cheaper Than Competitors, Study Finds
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
A price comparison in Israeli supermarkets found that private store brands are not always cheaper than competitors, with some instances showing them to be significantly more expensive. International research suggests retailers may influence consumer choice towards their own brands. A local price check revealed that in many cases, the price difference was minimal or even favored established brands, challenging the assumption that private labels guarantee savings.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Private store brands are not consistently cheaper than established brands in Israeli supermarkets.
- Some private label products were found to be significantly more expensive than competitors.
- International research suggests retailers may influence consumer choice towards their own brands.
- A local price check found private brands more expensive in several product categories.
- Consumers are advised to compare unit prices and be aware of sales on established brands.
A price comparison across four major Israeli supermarket chains reveals that private store brands are not consistently cheaper than established brands, and in some cases, are significantly more expensive. While private labels were historically promoted as a way for consumers to save money by avoiding advertising and marketing costs, this is not always the reality today.
International research suggests that supermarkets leverage their control over product selection and shelf placement to influence consumer choices, sometimes steering them towards their own brands. Studies from Purdue University and Yale University indicate that introducing private labels can lead to a reduction in the variety of competing manufacturer brands and potentially increase retailer profits. These findings, while not directly referencing Israel, highlight a global economic mechanism where retailers act as active participants in shaping consumer decisions.
A local price check on 14 product pairs found that in only three instances was the store brand cheaper by more than 10%. In three cases, the store brand was more expensive, and in five others, the price difference was less than 5%. For example, Rami Levy's private label Persian rice was found to be nearly 19% more expensive per 100 grams than a comparable Davat brand. Similarly, Shufersal's own brand of pickled cucumbers was about 23.7% more expensive than a Group of Yavne product.
The article also points out that the same factory may produce both a well-known brand and a store brand, but this does not guarantee identical quality, as specifications and ingredients can differ. Furthermore, the rise of distinct private brand names, rather than those simply bearing the supermarket's name, can create a false sense of wider variety while still being controlled by the same retailer. Consumers are urged to compare prices per unit, not just package size, and to be aware that sales on established brands can sometimes make them cheaper than private labels.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Centre 2