Otzma Yehudit Revives Bill to Redefine 'Who is a Jew' Under Law of Return
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
Otzma Yehudit has reintroduced a bill to redefine "who is a Jew" under Israel's Law of Return, aiming to restrict recognition of non-Orthodox conversions. The proposal, previously blocked by Prime Minister Netanyahu in the prior Knesset, seeks to give the state authority over conversion recognition. The bill has sparked debate over its potential impact on liberal Jewish movements and Diaspora Jewry, with divided public opinion in Israel. Legal experts are scrutinizing the bill's ambiguous wording and potential implications for both domestic and international conversions.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Otzma Yehudit reintroduced a bill to change the definition of 'who is a Jew' in Israel's Law of Return.
- The proposed legislation aims to restrict recognition of non-Orthodox conversions to Judaism.
- A 2021 High Court ruling mandated state recognition of non-Orthodox conversions performed in Israel.
- The bill's wording could affect private Orthodox conversions and conversions performed abroad.
- Supporters claim it ensures halakhic uniformity, while critics warn of diplomatic fallout with Diaspora Jewry.
- Public opinion in Israel is divided on recognizing non-Orthodox conversions.
Otzma Yehudit has reintroduced a legislative proposal aimed at altering the definition of "who is a Jew" within Israel's Law of Return, specifically targeting the recognition of non-Orthodox conversions. This move seeks to grant the state the authority to define Jewish identity, potentially impacting how conversions performed by Reform and Conservative movements are recognized.
The proposed change revives a contentious issue that has seen numerous petitions filed with the High Court of Justice (Bagatz) since 2005. In 2021, an expanded nine-judge panel ruled that the state must recognize non-Orthodox conversions performed in Israel within a recognized Jewish community for the purposes of the Law of Return, emphasizing it as a civil rather than religious matter.
The new proposal's wording, particularly the phrase "according to Halakha" (Jewish law), has raised legal questions. While proponents argue it aims to ensure halakhic uniformity and prevent conversions that are not recognized by Israel's Chief Rabbinate for marriage or burial, critics fear it could invalidate conversions performed by private Orthodox initiatives like "Giur Kahalacha," which are not officially sanctioned by the Rabbinate. The term "according to Halakha" itself is seen as ambiguous, potentially allowing for broader interpretations by the courts.
Furthermore, the bill does not differentiate between conversions performed in Israel and those conducted abroad. An analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute suggests that Reform and Conservative conversions performed overseas would no longer grant eligibility for immigration under the Law of Return. This is a significant consideration given that only a small percentage of American Jews identify as Orthodox, while larger segments adhere to Reform and Conservative Judaism.
Supporters of the bill, including MK Simcha Rothman, argue that it addresses a fundamental issue the Knesset has avoided for decades. Rothman has previously stated that the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism but to prevent "fictitious" or overly lenient conversions for immigration purposes, asserting that most conversions in traditional communities abroad are already performed according to Halakha.
The potential diplomatic fallout with American Jewry, a significant portion of whom do not adhere to Orthodoxy, is also a major concern. Public opinion in Israel is divided, with a recent poll indicating that 46% of Israeli Jews recognize individuals converted through non-Orthodox means as Jewish, while 39% do not. Additionally, 46% believe representatives from Diaspora communities should be involved in discussions regarding changes to the Law of Return.
Mentioned