Israeli Woman's Flight Cancellation Leads to Class Action Against ITA Airways
Translated & summarized from Calcalist by baba
A nearly 90-year-old Israeli woman and her son have had a class action lawsuit approved against ITA Airways after their flight from Rome to Tel Aviv was canceled during the war. The airline refunded the ticket but allegedly provided no alternative flights or assistance, forcing the passengers to incur significant expenses. The court ruled that while wartime emergency orders provided some exemptions, airlines still have a duty to assist passengers or offer alternative flights. The class action will cover affected passengers between October 2023 and November 2026.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- A class action lawsuit against ITA Airways was approved for a flight canceled during the war.
- An Israeli woman and her son were left stranded in Rome after their flight was canceled.
- The airline allegedly refunded tickets but provided no alternative flights or assistance.
- Passengers were forced to spend approximately 12,500 euros on alternative travel.
- The court ruled airlines still owe assistance or alternative flights during emergencies.
- The class action covers flights canceled or delayed between October 2023 and November 2026.
An Israeli woman, nearly 90 years old, and her son have successfully had a class action lawsuit approved against Italy's national airline, ITA Airways. Their flight from Rome to Tel Aviv was canceled during the war, leaving them stranded. Judge Avi Gorman of the Central District Court partially approved the request to proceed as a class action, with the case to be heard unless a settlement is reached.
The mother and son filed the request in 2024, detailing that their August 2024 return flight to Israel was canceled along with flights for 13 other family members. They received notice three days before departure. The airline, they claim, only refunded the cost of the canceled tickets, leaving them without alternative flights or assistance such as accommodation, food, and transportation, forcing them to spend approximately 12,500 euros out of pocket.
They argued that merely refunding the ticket price did not fulfill the airline's obligations, forcing them to act as "travel agents" to find a way back to Israel, which delayed their return by two days. Ultimately, they purchased new tickets, with family members returning separately via Cyprus and Athens.
ITA Airways sought to dismiss the lawsuit, citing the war that began on October 7, 2023, as the reason for the cancellation. They claimed the cancellation notice directed passengers to their information center for assistance, which the plaintiffs did not utilize. The airline maintained it refunded the canceled ticket and is not obligated to cover the cost of alternative tickets purchased elsewhere, asserting its compliance with aviation law.
Judge Gorman ruled that while a wartime emergency order exempted airlines from certain financial compensation, it did not negate their duty to provide assistance or offer alternative flights. He noted the airline's "evidentiary void" for failing to prove it provided these services. The judge stated that aviation law requires airlines to offer passengers assistance, a refund, or an alternative flight upon cancellation, and these obligations were not waived by the emergency order.
The class action will include anyone whose flight to or from Israel was canceled or delayed by ITA Airways between October 7, 2023, and November 11, 2026, and who did not receive assistance or an alternative flight. Individuals who have filed or will file personal lawsuits will be excluded. The request was not approved for the four years prior to the lawsuit's filing due to a lack of evidence from before the war. The judge emphasized that the court may consider the emergency situation when hearing the case but found no justification to dismiss the approval request outright.
Lawyer David Schwartzbaum stated that while the war can cancel flights, it does not cancel passenger rights, and airlines cannot leave people stranded without aid. He called the decision a significant achievement for the family and other affected passengers, vowing to ensure passenger rights are upheld. ITA Airways responded that the court's decision does not establish a violation of law or entitlement to compensation, acknowledging the court recognized the security context. The airline is reviewing its legal defense and will not comment further.
Mentioned
