Haredi Hegemony's Treatment of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef Mirrors Secular Elite's Stance on Netanyahu
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
The article argues that the Haredi Ashkenazi establishment's past ostracization of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef mirrors the secular elite's alleged treatment of Prime Minister Netanyahu. It claims the Haredi worldview prioritizes its own survival, believing it ensures the Jewish people's existence. The piece details how Rabbi Ovadia Yosef was marginalized by the Haredi hegemony for challenging their dominance. It also notes historical opposition within the Haredi world to easier Talmudic study methods and a recent positive shift in the Religious Zionist community's view of Mizrahi traditions.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Haredi Ashkenazi elite ostracized Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, similar to secular elite's alleged treatment of Netanyahu.
- Haredi worldview prioritizes public survival, believing it ensures Jewish people's survival.
- Haredi hegemony historically suppressed Sephardic leader Rabbi Ovadia Yosef and his followers.
- Haredi establishment historically opposed easier Talmudic study methods.
- Religious Zionist community shows a positive shift towards Mizrahi traditions.
The article draws a parallel between the Haredi Ashkenazi establishment's ostracization of Sephardic spiritual leader Rabbi Ovadia Yosef and the secular elite's alleged treatment of Prime Minister Netanyahu. It posits that the Haredi worldview prioritizes the survival of the Haredi public, believing their existence ensures the survival of the Jewish people, a concept exemplified by Rabbi Shach's teachings.
The author argues that the Haredi Ashkenazi hegemony, aided by external secular forces that weakened Sephardic Jews, continues to dominate the Sephardic community. This dominance, the article suggests, prevented Shas from aligning with the left-wing bloc, unlike the Ashkenazi Haredi party United Torah Judaism.
Historically, the article recounts, when Shas attempted to assert its independence in the early 1990s, the Haredi hegemony retaliated by marginalizing Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, discrediting his Torah scholarship and persecuting his followers. This suppression, the author claims, continued until after Rabbi Ovadia Yosef's death, when the perceived threat to the established power balance subsided.
The piece further contends that hegemonic groups, whether secular or religious, tend to marginalize charismatic leaders like Rabbi Ovadia Yosef and Netanyahu, who disrupt the existing order. The article also touches upon the Haredi establishment's historical opposition to Rabbi Steinzaltz's annotated Gemara and the continued criticism by Rabbi Shach's grandson, Rabbi Bergman, of the widely accepted Schottenstein edition of the Talmud, which is seen as facilitating easier study.
Finally, the article notes a significant shift in the Religious Zionist community's attitude towards Mizrahi (Sephardic) traditions, suggesting a growing connection to the "Second Israel" concept, which contrasts idealized Western ideologies with imperfect Eastern traditions, citing singer Ben Tzur as an example.