MLS League Under Fire for Harming Israeli Football and National Team
Translated & summarized from Sport5 by baba
Israeli football commentators are increasingly blaming the MLS for negatively impacting the national team, despite limited player representation. The article argues this criticism is unfair, drawing parallels to past skepticism towards the Belgian league, which has since gained legitimacy. While acknowledging the MLS's flaws, the author suggests it's a developing league offering legitimate opportunities and that judging it prematurely is simplistic. The national team's struggles, the piece concludes, predate the MLS trend.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Israeli football commentators are blaming the MLS for harming the national team and players.
- Criticism of the MLS is often automatic and dismisses it as a 'retirement league'.
- The article compares the current perception of MLS to past skepticism towards the Belgian league.
- Many Israeli players have struggled to advance from the Belgian league to top European clubs.
- The MLS is described as a developing league with growing legitimacy and investment in player development.
- The author argues that judging the MLS prematurely is superficial and unfair.
The recent September-October 2026 national team window has sparked a debate in Israeli football, with many blaming the MLS (Major League Soccer) for harming the Israeli player and the national team. This criticism emerged despite the fact that only six MLS players were part of the 26-man squad, collectively playing only 14% of the total minutes in the four games.
The influx of Israeli footballers to the US intensified after October 2023, often met with automatic criticism such as "went only for the money," "won't return to Europe," or "retirement league." The article argues that these perceptions dismiss the MLS as a viable league for growth, comparing it to past criticisms of the Chinese league when a national team striker played there.
The author challenges the notion that the MLS is inherently detrimental, drawing a parallel with the Belgian league. For years, Belgium was considered an ideal European stepping stone for Israeli players, offering competitiveness and exposure. However, a look back reveals that many Israeli players who moved to Belgium struggled to establish themselves or advance to top European leagues. Only recently have players like Anan Khalaily and Omri Gandelman successfully transitioned from the Belgian league to top-tier European clubs, and even Khalaily's move to Belgium faced initial skepticism.
The article posits that the MLS, like the Belgian league in its past, is a developing and improving league investing in infrastructure and player development, gradually becoming a legitimate option for young footballers. It highlights the MLS's dual role as an attractive league for established players and an investment in youth development, with its large size allowing for diverse club strategies. The presence of former MLS players like Alphonso Davies and Tyler Adams in major European leagues, and the increasing scouting of talent from the US and Canada, are cited as evidence of its growing legitimacy.
While acknowledging the MLS's drawbacks, such as the lack of promotion and relegation and a strict salary cap, the article concludes that judging the league prematurely is superficial. It suggests that the MLS, in some aspects, is as competitive and professional as some second-tier European leagues. The author also points out that the Israeli national team's performance issues predated the move of players to the US, urging for a more balanced assessment of the MLS and giving it fair consideration, much like the evolving perception of the Belgian league.