Glass Factory and Insurer Ordered to Pay NIS 312,000 to Injured Worker
Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba
A glass factory and its insurer, The Phoenix, must pay approximately NIS 312,000 to a 60-year-old maintenance worker injured by an electric saw in 2018. The worker was trimming trees on company property when the saw recoiled and struck him. The court found the employer negligent for assigning the task without proper training or equipment, though the worker shared 10% of the blame. The compensation will be in addition to National Insurance benefits.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- A glass factory and its insurer must pay NIS 312,000 to a worker injured by an electric saw.
- The worker was injured in 2018 while trimming trees on company property.
- The court found the employer negligent for assigning the task without proper training or equipment.
- The worker was assigned 10% contributory negligence for his role in the accident.
- The worker sustained a permanent disability of approximately 23% from the injury.
A glass factory and its insurance company, The Phoenix, have been ordered by the Herzliya Magistrate's Court to pay approximately NIS 312,000 to a 60-year-old maintenance worker who was injured by an electric saw while trimming trees in May 2018. The compensation will be in addition to National Insurance benefits and legal fees.
The worker, a long-time employee responsible for maintaining production machinery, claimed he was asked by one of the factory owners to trim tree branches that were scratching his car. He took an electric disc saw from the warehouse and, after successfully trimming two trees, the saw encountered a hard object on the third tree. The saw then recoiled, striking his left hand and right thigh, causing a deep cut.
He was given first aid by a factory owner before being evacuated to Kaplan Hospital, where he underwent surgery. The worker argued that gardening was not part of his job, and he received no proper training or safety equipment. He stated he complied with the order out of fear of being fired by the "tough" owner.
The factory and The Phoenix contended that the experienced worker was familiar with the tools and that the accident was due to his own carelessness. They presented surveillance footage showing him performing physical tasks to dispute claims of functional limitations.
However, Judge Yossi Berachia ruled that the employer was negligent for assigning a task outside the worker's responsibilities using an inappropriate tool for tree trimming, without providing instruction or safety gear. The judge also found the company violated safety regulations. The worker was assigned 10% contributory negligence for choosing the saw himself without verifying its suitability and not requesting safety instructions, though the court acknowledged his fear of losing his livelihood.
The court-appointed expert determined the worker sustained a permanent disability of approximately 23%. The judge accepted this, noting the worker's limitations could affect his future earning capacity, even though he has since earned more than before the accident. His damages were assessed at NIS 475,000 for lost earnings, assistance, medical expenses, and pain and suffering. After deducting the contributory negligence and National Insurance benefits, the final amount was determined. The factory and The Phoenix were also ordered to cover legal fees and expert witness costs.