Israel's Supreme Court Upholds Strict Prison Rules for Red Cross Visits
Translated & summarized from Mignews by baba
Israel's High Court of Justice has upheld strict new rules for the International Committee of the Red Cross visiting security prisoners, dismissing a petition from civil rights advocates. The regulations, implemented by the Prison Service, severely limit access and require prior security checks. Despite a June court order to resume inspections, the Red Cross has not visited any prisoners due to these new conditions, which include bans on certain electronic devices and restricted meeting formats. The organization is in dialogue with Israeli authorities to resume visits under international standards.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Israel's High Court upheld strict Prison Service rules for Red Cross visits to security prisoners.
- The court dismissed a petition by the Association for Civil Rights seeking to punish the state for non-compliance.
- New regulations limit ICRC visits to once per quarter with a maximum of five individuals after security checks.
- Access is denied to prisoners under investigation, in solitary, or deemed highly dangerous.
- Meetings are now 30-minute sessions through a partition, and delegates cannot request medical exams.
- The ICRC has not visited any prisoners since June due to the new, restrictive rules.
Israel's High Court of Justice, known as the Bagatz, has upheld strict regulations imposed by the Prison Service (Shabas) on visits by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) to prisoners accused of security offenses. The court dismissed a petition from the Association for Civil Rights, which sought to punish the state for contempt of court and failure to comply with a June ruling. The judges deemed the petition resolved but left the door open for future reconsideration.
The court's decision was based on state assurances that Shabas and the IDF would facilitate individual meetings for the humanitarian mission. However, since the June ruling mandating the resumption of inspections, ICRC representatives have not visited any prisoners. The organization has been unable to operate due to new rules implemented by Shabas head Kobi Yaacobi for a six-month period.
These regulations significantly restrict the ICRC's access. Each visit now requires prior security checks, and the frequency is limited to once per quarter with a pre-approved list of no more than five individuals. Access is completely denied to those under investigation, in solitary confinement, or classified as "highly dangerous." Meetings have shifted from unmonitored cell conversations to 30-minute individual sessions through a partition with an intercom, and prison wardens can terminate conversations early.
Furthermore, delegates are no longer permitted to request medical examinations of detainees and must undergo mandatory security screenings upon entry, with a complete ban on phones, smartwatches, computers, and recording devices. Israel initially imposed a total ban on such visits after the October 7th events due to the ICRC's lack of access to Israeli hostages in Gaza, but these restrictions persisted even after the return of surviving captives.
The situation has been accompanied by intensified detention conditions initiated by National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, reports of prisoner mistreatment, and a failed attempt by the ruling coalition to codify the ban into law via the Knesset. Oded Feller, an attorney for the Association for Civil Rights, criticized the court's refusal to enforce its own ruling, calling it a "dead letter." He argued that Shabas intentionally drafted the instructions to make the ICRC's mission practically impossible, leading the organization to refuse to work under such conditions. The ICRC stated it is continuing dialogue with Israeli authorities and hopes to resume visits according to its international standards soon.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Other 1
