Rabbi Yaniv Explains Why He Stopped Protesting Haredi Draft Evasion
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Rabbi Shmuel Yaniv has stopped protesting Haredi draft evasion at the entrance to Bnei Brak, despite not changing his views on the importance of military service. He explained that his decision is motivated by a desire to avoid harming Torah scholars and the world of Torah study. Rabbi Yaniv, who lost three grandsons in attacks and combat, highlighted the spiritual contributions of the Haredi community and the necessity of both Torah study and defending the land. He hopes for a solution to the draft law that balances these values and promotes national unity.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Rabbi Shmuel Yaniv ceased protests against Haredi draft evasion, citing concern for Torah scholars.
- He lost three grandsons in attacks and combat, including two in the February 2023 Huwara attack.
- Yaniv emphasized the spiritual importance of the Haredi community's dedication to Torah study.
- He affirmed his belief in the necessity of both Torah study and defending the land.
- Rabbi Yaniv hopes for a draft law solution that balances religious study and military service.
Rabbi Shmuel Yaniv, who lost three grandsons in attacks and combat, has decided to cease his protests at the entrance to Bnei Brak against the exemption of Haredi men from military service. In an interview with Channel 7, he clarified that his stance on the importance of military service has not changed, but he fears that continuing the demonstrations could be perceived as an attack on Torah scholars and the world of Torah study.
Rabbi Yaniv, a student of Rabbi Zvi Yehuda HaCohen Kook, explained that his decision stems from his love for Torah and the Jewish people. He noted that his previous protests were motivated by the belief that Israel's wars are "mitzvah wars" and part of the redemptive process. However, he now emphasizes the significant spiritual contribution of the Haredi community, stating, "What the Haredi public clings to Torah and scholars, and engages in Torah by the hundreds of thousands, is unprecedented. It is wonderful. It is the light of the Torah, it revives us, it nourishes our soul. Without it, we have nothing."
Despite his appreciation for Torah study, Rabbi Yaniv maintains his belief in the importance of defending the land, recalling his own service in the Six-Day War and the Yom Kippur War. He stated, "If I now shout and protest, I feel it crosses the line, as if I am destroying the world of Torah. I will not destroy the world of Torah." He described Torah study and defending the land as two essential pillars, "Yachin and Boaz," both necessary for Israel's existence.
Regarding the draft law, Rabbi Yaniv expressed hope for a solution that allows those dedicated to Torah study to continue their pursuits, while also acknowledging the necessity of military service. He concluded by emphasizing that they will protest as much as possible without disrespecting Torah scholars or Torah itself, aiming to sanctify God's name and foster unity among all segments of the people.
Mentioned
