Shin Bet Internal Disputes Erupt Over Election Bribery Probe in Arab Community

Internal disputes are escalating within the Israeli Security Agency (Shin Bet) concerning an investigation into alleged election bribery within the Arab community. Accusations are being exchanged between individuals familiar with the investigation and those close to Shin Bet chief Duvdevani, stemming from a lack of investigative materials to support Duvdevani's public statements on the matter. Channel 13 reported that sources close to the investigation stated Duvdevani has not submitted supporting materials, suggesting the case is "in its final stages of dying" unless he possesses additional undisclosed evidence. These sources also highlighted difficulties in distinguishing between intelligence information, legal evidence, and tangible materials suitable for launching a formal investigation, warning the case might conclude without concrete results.

Conversely, sources close to Duvdevani asserted that the agency aims to deepen the investigation but faces operational constraints. They maintained that the materials presented are sufficient for questioning individuals involved. Duvdevani had previously stated in closed discussions that the sums linked to the alleged election bribery do not exceed 100 million shekels, but are less than that amount.

The disagreements occur amidst tension between the Shin Bet and the Israeli Police regarding case handling procedures. Following a joint meeting involving representatives from the Shin Bet, Police, and State Prosecution, Police Investigations Division head Boaz Pelat emphasized the need to standardize operational procedures among the involved parties. Pelat reportedly requested in a text message that all materials transferred to the Shin Bet first pass through his office, with sources close to him explaining that the case's sensitivity necessitates clear, organized inter-agency protocols.

Channel 13 noted that Pelat's directive could be perceived as a confrontation with the Shin Bet, though the police are expected to clarify the instructions' rationale. Subsequently, a joint task force was established, including representatives from the Shin Bet, State Prosecution, the Police's Lahav 433 unit, and the Investigations Division. The police stated they have received materials from the Shin Bet and are analyzing them to prepare a professional assessment, with another meeting scheduled to discuss future steps. The nature and sufficiency of the available evidence for launching investigations into the election bribery allegations remain a point of contention among the involved parties.