Arutz ShevaSecurity22:03

Supreme Court Delays Sentence for Convicted Killer Pending Appeal

By ערוץ 7

Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba

RightNeutral tone

Hebrew · 3 newsrooms covering

Plus

Israel's Supreme Court has unusually delayed the start of a 13-year prison sentence for a young man convicted of killing Aisha al-Rabi in 2018. Justice Ruth Ronen ruled that the convicted individual, who was a minor at the time of the offense, will await the outcome of his appeal. The decision considered the conviction's reliance on circumstantial evidence and the dissenting opinion in the lower court, aiming to prevent potential unjust imprisonment.

The story in 5 lines · by baba

Supreme Court delays 13-year sentence for 2018 killing conviction pending appeal.
Justice Ruth Ronen cited circumstantial evidence and a dissenting lower court opinion.
The convicted individual was a minor at the time of Aisha al-Rabi's death.
Delay aims to prevent potential unjust imprisonment if the appeal is successful.
Defense lawyers hope for a full acquittal based on the Supreme Court's decision.

Israel's Supreme Court has unusually decided to postpone the start of a prison sentence for a young man convicted of killing Aisha al-Rabi in 2018. Justice Ruth Ronen ordered that the convicted individual, who was sentenced to 13 years in prison, will not begin serving his term until his appeal is heard. This means he will remain out of prison for the time being, awaiting the court's decision on his appeal against the conviction.

The decision to delay the sentence was made after the Supreme Court reviewed the circumstances of the conviction, which was based on circumstantial evidence. It also considered that the initial ruling in the District Court was by a majority of two judges, with one judge dissenting and believing the defendant should have been acquitted due to doubt.

Aisha al-Rabi was killed in 2018 when a rock was thrown at the car she was traveling in with her family, hitting her. The defendant, who was a minor at the time of the incident, was prosecuted for his involvement. The Lod District Court convicted him in September, and he was sentenced to 13 years. His defense team appealed to the Supreme Court, requesting the sentence be delayed.

Justice Ronen granted the request, stating that the case warranted an exception to the general rule that convicted individuals begin serving their sentences while an appeal is pending. She explained that if the appeal is successful and the defendant is acquitted, he would have served no time in prison. Therefore, sending him to prison before the appeal could lead to him serving a sentence unjustly.

Another key reason for the decision was the perceived merits of the appeal, especially given the disagreement among the district court judges. Ronen also took into account the defendant's personal circumstances and behavior since the incident. She noted that eight years have passed since al-Rabi's death, during which the defendant has remained out of prison and committed no further offenses. He has no prior criminal record, and was a minor when the crime occurred.

The defendant's lawyers, Yrom Halevy and Adi Kidar from the Honenu organization, expressed hope that the Supreme Court would adopt the dissenting judge's opinion from the lower court, leading to a full acquittal. They called the decision a "precedent-setting" step that paves the way for their client's complete exoneration.