US Right's Shifting Ideology Challenges Israel's Assured Support
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
The American right is experiencing an ideological shift, questioning core liberal principles and emphasizing tradition and community over individual rights. This evolution challenges Israel's assumption of guaranteed support from the U.S. right, requiring Jerusalem to demonstrate practical value to American national security. The article notes a parallel debate within Israeli conservatism about its relationship with liberalism, urging it to choose a tradition that synthesizes liberty and established institutions.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- The American right is shifting away from traditional liberalism, questioning individual rights and emphasizing community.
- This ideological change means Israel can no longer assume automatic support from the U.S. right.
- Jerusalem must now prove its practical contribution to U.S. national security to maintain support.
- A debate is occurring within American conservatism about its relationship with liberalism.
- Israeli conservatism must choose which intellectual tradition to embrace amidst these shifts.
The American right is undergoing a significant ideological shift, moving away from traditional conservative principles towards a more protectionist and critical stance on liberalism. This evolution is marked by a more lenient attitude towards figures like Vladimir Putin, a departure from free trade, and a questioning of foundational liberal tenets. Some factions of this new right, sometimes termed 'post-liberal,' identify liberalism itself as the primary adversary, arguing that it overemphasizes individual rights at the expense of community, tradition, and the 'good life.' Critics contend that liberalism, by focusing on procedural rights rather than virtues, contributes to Western cultural crises.
While acknowledging the need for community and tradition beyond individual rights, the article argues that abandoning liberalism entirely is a mistake. Political liberalism's role, it posits, is to enable diverse beliefs within a framework that limits governmental power and protects social institutions from state overreach. The rise of this new right in the U.S. has profound implications for allies like Israel, necessitating a reassessment of foreign policy.
Israel can no longer assume unwavering support from the American right based solely on religious or historical ties. Jerusalem must now demonstrate its practical contribution to U.S. national security and navigate the evolving power dynamics within the Republican party. While engaging pragmatically with the new right, Israel should not compromise its own intellectual traditions.
The article highlights an internal debate within conservatism regarding its relationship with liberalism. One side views liberalism as an enemy to be defeated, while the other recognizes the Anglo-American tradition's strength in integrating liberal freedoms with conservative institutions and virtues. This debate is also playing out in Israel, as evidenced by the National Conservatism Conference in Jerusalem.
Israeli conservatism faces a crucial choice: to align with a tradition that seeks to overcome liberalism or one that embraces the synthesis of liberty and tradition. As parts of the American right distance themselves from their liberal heritage, Israeli conservatism is urged to strengthen its ties with those who defend it and to cultivate its own intellectual tradition for future generations.
Mentioned