Avi Nesher's New Film Tackles October 7th With Superficiality
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
Avi Nesher's new film, "Our Loves," attempts to portray the October 7th trauma through multiple character storylines, aiming for an emotional and cathartic experience. However, the film is criticized for its superficiality, clichéd dialogue, and melodramatic treatment of sensitive narratives. The reviewer argues that the movie fails to provide a deep or nuanced exploration of the events, likening it to a generic Netflix production and suggesting a more profound cinematic approach is needed.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Avi Nesher's new film "Our Loves" explores the October 7th trauma through multiple character arcs.
- The film is criticized for its superficiality, clichéd dialogue, and melodramatic approach.
- Reviewer questions audience readiness for a Hollywood-style fictional portrayal of national trauma.
- Nesher's intent to show unity and strength emerging from the events is noted but deemed poorly executed.
- The script and political commentary are also cited as significant weaknesses in the film.
Director Avi Nesher's new film, "Our Loves," attempts to grapple with the trauma of October 7th by following multiple characters whose personal struggles are swept into a survival journey following the events. While the film is expected to provide an emotional and cathartic experience for many viewers, the reviewer criticizes it as one of Nesher's weaker cinematic efforts, questioning whether audiences are ready for a Hollywood-style fictional portrayal of such a profound national trauma.
Nesher's intention, according to the review, was to depict a diverse group of Israelis, including an Ethiopian police officer and an Arab surgeon, who emerge from the ordeal stronger and more united. However, the film's reliance on generic storylines and melodramatic treatment is seen as a missed opportunity and potentially trivializing the event. The reviewer likens the narratives of a divorced father dealing with child custody, a religious woman finding love unexpectedly, and a police officer whose mother accepts her same-sex relationship, to those found in mediocre films like "Crash."
The script itself is also heavily criticized for its weak, artificial, and clichéd dialogue, which even experienced actors struggle to deliver convincingly. Furthermore, the film's political aspect is deemed problematic, with Nesher allegedly using constant coverage of Channel 12 news and a minor but vocal character to assign blame for the events, which the reviewer finds jarring and unnecessary.
Ultimately, "Our Loves" is described as a comforting emotional journey for Israelis but one that is superficial, clichéd, and lacking perspective, relying on basic emotional manipulation. The review suggests the film resembles a "Netflix October 7th movie" and argues that Israelis deserve a more profound, honest, and complex cinematic treatment of the events, recommending the final season of "Fauda" as a successful example.