Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

YnetGeneral

Legal Doctrine Shifts Burden of Proof in Medical Malpractice Cases

Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba

CenterNeutral tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

In Israeli medical malpractice lawsuits, the doctrine of "res ipsa loquitur" can shift the burden of proof from the patient to the medical provider. This legal tool, outlined in Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance, applies when a patient is unaware of the cause of harm and the event suggests negligence. The reversal is crucial in cases with missing medical records or unperformed tests, requiring the provider to prove they were not negligent. Lawyer Amit Oriah notes this can be a winning strategy in suitable cases.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • The doctrine of "res ipsa loquitur" can shift the burden of proof in Israeli medical malpractice cases.
  • Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance allows for this burden reversal under specific conditions.
  • Patients often face an information gap due to their non-medical status and sedation during procedures.
  • Missing medical records or unperformed tests can lead to the burden of proof shifting to the defendant.
  • Lawyer Amit Oriah highlights the importance of evidentiary analysis in these lawsuits.
  • The shift in burden requires the medical provider to prove the absence of negligence.

In medical malpractice lawsuits, patients often face a significant information gap. When a patient undergoes surgery and wakes up with an unexplained injury, they may not know if a mistake occurred, if an unusual event happened, or if the medical team followed standard procedures. This difficulty is compounded because the patient is not a medical professional, may be sedated during the procedure, and the events are primarily documented by the medical staff. This disparity in information is where the legal doctrine of "res ipsa loquitur," or "the thing speaks for itself," can become a crucial tool.

Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance in Israel allows for the reversal of the burden of proof in certain malpractice cases. If specific conditions are met, the responsibility to prove whether negligence occurred shifts from the plaintiff (the patient) to the defendant (the medical provider). These conditions include the patient not knowing or being unable to know the circumstances that caused the harm, the harm being caused by an asset under the defendant's full control, and the circumstances of the event suggesting a lack of reasonable care by the defendant more than the presence of it.

The implications of this shift are dramatic. Instead of the patient needing to detail exactly how the medical team was negligent, the medical provider must convince the court that no negligence took place. This is particularly impactful in cases with factual ambiguity, where the burden of persuasion can determine the outcome.

Reversal of the burden of proof can also arise in cases of evidentiary damage. If a crucial piece of information that should have been documented in a patient's medical record is missing, and this absence hinders the patient's ability to prove their case, a court may shift the burden of proof to the defendant. This applies not only to missing records but also to situations where a necessary diagnostic test was not performed. Lawyer Amit Oriah emphasizes that managing a medical malpractice claim requires a deep understanding of the evidentiary aspects, including what information is available, what is missing, who had knowledge at the time, and who should bear the burden of proof for disputed facts.

While reversing the burden of proof does not guarantee a successful lawsuit, as the plaintiff still needs to build their case, it can be a decisive advantage in appropriate circumstances. It allows the focus to shift from proving what happened in the operating room to requiring the party who treated and documented the events to explain why the resulting harm was not due to negligence.

YnetCentre · Rishon LeZion

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire