Haredi Autonomy Threatens Israel's Future, Needs Dismantling
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
The article argues that the "Haredi autonomy" in Israel, characterized by economic unsustainability and systemic mismanagement, poses a threat to the state's future. Haredi municipalities consistently rank among the poorest, despite state subsidies, and face severe infrastructure and financial issues. Problems within the Haredi education system and alleged corruption in municipal governance are highlighted as evidence of a broader systemic failure. The author calls for dismantling this autonomy before it destabilizes the country, emphasizing the need for all citizens to be treated equally under the law.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Haredi population growth necessitates addressing the unsustainable economic model reliant on state resources.
- Haredi municipalities are among Israel's poorest, facing continuous socioeconomic decline.
- Severe infrastructure and financial mismanagement issues plague Haredi cities like Bnei Brak.
- Irregularities and alleged corruption are reported in Haredi municipalities and educational institutions.
- The article calls for dismantling "Haredi autonomy" to prevent it from destabilizing the state.
As the Haredi population in Israel is projected to constitute a significant portion of the country by 2050, with one in four Israelis expected to be Haredi, the current economic model supporting this community is deemed unsustainable. This model relies heavily on state resources and the contributions of other citizens across various sectors, including security and the economy. The urgency of addressing this issue intensifies with upcoming elections.
When asked about the challenges posed by the growing Haredi population, MK Yitzhak Pindrus suggested looking at Jerusalem as an example of a thriving city despite its large Haredi community. However, the article points out that Jerusalem is heavily dependent on state grants. Instead, it proposes examining Haredi municipalities to predict the nation's future, noting that these cities consistently rank among the poorest in Israel. Jerusalem, Beit Shemesh, and Bnei Brak are highlighted as the top three largest impoverished cities, with Modi'in Illit, Beitar Illit, and Rekhasim also appearing on the list. This situation is described as a continuous decline, with Beitar Illit, Modi'in Illit, Beit Shemesh, and Jerusalem experiencing the most significant drops in socioeconomic ranking in recent decades, largely due to rapid Haredi population growth.
Despite the poverty of residents, some Haredi municipalities like Bnei Brak generate substantial revenue from commercial areas and state subsidies. Nevertheless, the article details severe infrastructure problems, including sewage-flooded streets, rat infestations, and garbage piles, alongside a reported deficit of tens of millions of shekels. Opposition council member Yaakov Weider has long exposed mismanagement, sanitation issues, excessive senior staff salaries, publicly funded travel, and exorbitant hospitality budgets. Past investigations have also revealed alleged fund allocations to fictitious entities, and during a recent emergency, it was discovered that bomb shelters had been converted into synagogues and organizational offices, rendering them unavailable to residents seeking protection from missile attacks.
Similar issues of irregularities, including construction violations, encroachment on public spaces, and conflicts of interest in tenders, have surfaced in Elad. In Beit Shemesh, land designated for educational institutions was reportedly converted into residential and commercial areas without proper permits. Within the Haredi education system, problems include delayed pension payments for teachers, institutional discrimination in seminar admissions, and the diversion of education funds for election campaigning.
The article argues that these are not isolated incidents but systemic failures, suggesting that parts of the Haredi establishment treat state laws as mere recommendations. It posits that the Haredi community, having grown as an insular society, lacks the tools for modern public administration and that a society without leadership committed to internal lawfulness will struggle to manage a state system that includes non-Haredi citizens. The article concludes that the "Haredi autonomy" created by Israel's long-standing neglect of these issues now threatens the nation's future and must be dismantled before it destabilizes the country, emphasizing this is a call for the future well-being of all Israeli citizens.
Mentioned