Israel's Supreme Court Dismisses Petition Against Anonymous Sperm Donation
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
Israel's Supreme Court dismissed a five-and-a-half-year-old petition against anonymous sperm donation without ruling on the core issue of a child's right to know their biological father. The court cited ongoing procedural updates by the Ministry of Health, deeming the challenge premature. Petitioners criticized the decision, arguing it allows continued harm to children and avoids a fundamental rights question. The state was ordered to pay 8,000 shekels in legal costs.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Israel's Supreme Court dismissed a petition challenging anonymous sperm donation after five and a half years.
- The court did not rule on a child's right to know their biological father, citing ongoing Ministry of Health procedures.
- Petitioners "Bocharim B'Mishpacha" and "BeTzalmo" criticized the court for avoiding a fundamental rights decision.
- The Ministry of Health is still finalizing new directives for sperm banks, with discussions on public comments ongoing.
- The state was ordered to pay 8,000 shekels in legal costs to the petitioners.
Israel's Supreme Court has dismissed a petition filed five and a half years ago that challenged the anonymity policy for sperm donors. The court did not rule on the fundamental question of whether a child can be denied the right to know their biological father. The petition was submitted in 2021 by the "Bocharim B'Mishpacha" organization, affiliated with "Chotam," and the "BeTzalmo" organization. They sought to cancel Section 24 of the Ministry of Health's directive, which governs sperm banks and mandates that the identities of sperm donors and recipients remain confidential, thus permitting only anonymous donations.
Justices Dafna Barak-Erez, Ofer Groskopf, and Ruth Ronen stated that due to ongoing updates to the Ministry of Health's procedures, the petition in its current form was no longer appropriate for deliberation. During the proceedings, the Ministry of Health indicated it was developing a new directive for sperm banks. A draft of this directive was released for public comment in 2025, but discussions on the feedback are still ongoing. The petitioners argued that the new directive would likely maintain anonymity and therefore a decision on the core legal issue was warranted. However, the court disagreed, deeming arguments against the future arrangement premature as long as the Ministry's work was incomplete. The judges emphasized they were not taking a stance on the substance of the claims and ordered the petition's dismissal, preserving the parties' rights.
Alongside the dismissal, the court ordered the state to pay the petitioners 8,000 shekels in legal costs, acknowledging the lengthy period before the new directive's draft was formulated. Following the decision, Michal Po'er, chairman of "Bocharim B'Mishpacha," sharply criticized the Supreme Court. He stated that the court avoided ruling on the simple question of whether a child can be denied the right to know their biological father, suggesting the ministry delayed the process and the court allowed the continued harm to children.
Attorney Yehuda Po'er from "BeTzalmo" echoed these sentiments, lamenting that thousands of children born since the petition was filed will not know their fathers due to the court's refusal to address the anonymity issue. He contrasted this with recent Supreme Court decisions that he felt showed greater commitment to ensuring the rights of Arab individuals, questioning why similar diligence was not applied to protecting the rights of children born through sperm donation.