Aunt Wins Court Battle Over NIS 326,000 in Late Father's Accounts
Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba
A Tel Aviv family court awarded a woman NIS 326,648 from her late father's accounts, ruling the funds were hers and not part of his estate. The money included car accident compensation and lottery winnings, deposited for safekeeping. The judge found the daughter's evidence more credible than her nephews' claims of family settlements. The nephews were also ordered to pay NIS 15,000 in legal costs.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- A woman was awarded NIS 326,648 from her late father's accounts by a Tel Aviv family court.
- The court ruled funds from compensation and lottery winnings were held in trust, not part of the estate.
- The judge found the daughter's evidence of safekeeping more convincing than the nephews' claims.
- The nephews were ordered to pay the aunt NIS 15,000 in legal costs.
- The father died in 2023, leaving a will that did not mention these specific funds.
A family court in Tel Aviv recently ruled in favor of a woman who sued her two nephews, demanding approximately NIS 326,000 from her late father's bank accounts. The judge, Tzipi Cohen Avitan, was convinced that the funds, which included compensation from a car accident and lottery winnings, were deposited with the father for safekeeping only and were not part of his estate. The father passed away in 2023, leaving behind a widow, two daughters, and grandchildren. His 2019 will bequeathed his assets to his widow, one daughter, and three grandchildren from his second daughter, with special instructions regarding two taxi licenses he owned.
The daughter, who is an heir, filed a lawsuit claiming that in the three years preceding her father's death, she transferred funds belonging to her to his accounts, as per their agreement. She stated the deposits were intended for saving to buy an apartment, as she tended to be wasteful. The claim specifically mentioned NIS 115,358 in compensation from a car accident, winnings from "Chance" lotteries, VAT refunds, and rent for a taxi license she purchased with her own money, along with other bank transfers.
Her mother supported her account, confirming that her husband held the money for their daughter to prevent her from spending it. Conversely, the inheriting grandchildren argued that the funds belonged to the estate. They contended that their grandfather did not specify in his will that the money in his accounts belonged to their aunt, nor did she present an agreement to that effect. They suggested the money was part of family settlements, including expenses incurred by their grandfather and grandmother for raising the plaintiff's son.
However, Judge Cohen Avitan accepted the daughter's version, ruling she met the heightened burden of proof required for claims against an estate. The court found her claims were supported by documents and testimonies, while the nephews' assertion of family settlements remained speculative. Evidence presented included proof of deposit for the compensation funds, lottery win confirmations, and testimony from a lottery stand owner who confirmed the daughter asked for a check to be made out to her father. The ruling also noted that the nephews themselves admitted their aunt participated in lotteries, unlike their grandfather.
Regarding the taxi license, the judge relied on purchase documents and a broker's testimony that the deceased had told him the license was intended for his daughter. This testimony was deemed credible and objective. The court determined that the VAT refund and rental income related to the license also belonged to the daughter. Additionally, the plaintiff presented a note her father had photographed, listing amounts of NIS 199,500 and $4,100, which she claimed served as confirmation of her funds being held in his custody. Ultimately, the lawsuit was fully granted, awarding the daughter NIS 326,648 from her father's accounts. The nephews were ordered to pay her NIS 15,000 in legal costs.
Mentioned
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.