Reservists Join Identity Party, Demand 'Conquest, Expulsion, Settlement' in Gaza
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Two Israeli reservists, Roi Kirshberg and Captain (Res.) Omer Patsiniash Valdman, have joined the Identity Party, criticizing the government's war strategy and demanding a decisive outcome in Gaza. After extensive reserve duty since October 7, they feel soldiers' sacrifices have been in vain due to a lack of clear objectives and repeated tactical setbacks. The reservists advocate for "conquest, expulsion, settlement" in Gaza and criticize perceived false security, warning of future attacks if Hamas is allowed to rebuild. They aim to influence policy, even supporting Prime Minister Netanyahu if he adopts their decisive approach.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Reservists Roi Kirshberg and Omer Patsiniash Valdman joined the Identity Party, demanding decisive action in Gaza.
- They expressed frustration over prolonged fighting without achieving a clear victory since October 7.
- The reservists advocate for "conquest, expulsion, settlement" as the solution for Gaza.
- They warned that the current perceived quiet in Gaza is deceptive and Hamas is rearming.
- The reservists criticized US involvement for limiting Israel's operational freedom.
- They aim to bring their vision to the political arena through the Identity Party's 'Fighters with Identity' branch.
Two reservist soldiers, Roi Kirshberg and Captain (Res.) Omer Patsiniash Valdman, have joined the Identity Party, forming its "Fighters with Identity" branch. After hundreds of days in reserve duty since October 7, they express frustration with the government's handling of the war, arguing that the sacrifices made by soldiers have not yielded the desired decisive outcome.
Kirshberg, who has served over 700 days on various fronts, described repeatedly conquering areas only to see them lost again, lamenting the lack of a clear objective to defeat the enemy. He stated that the prolonged and seemingly ineffective effort is mentally exhausting, despite the high morale and willingness of Israelis to serve. Patsiniash Valdman recalled her emotional state in the early days of the war, crying for fallen friends and the nation, and expressed disappointment that even now, a year later, she doesn't feel the pride she hoped for.
Both reservists are critical of the current situation in Gaza, with Kirshberg refuting claims of complete destruction and noting that large areas remain untouched. Patsiniash Valdman described a recent visit to the border where they were warned away due to sniper fire, which she interpreted as evidence of a false sense of security. She warned that Hamas is rebuilding and rearming, and another October 7 is inevitable if the enemy remains.
Kirshberg, a former Identity Party activist, believes the October 7th attack has made it imperative to address the threat from Gaza directly, arguing that past governments, both left and right, have failed to do so. Patsiniash Valdman echoed this, emphasizing that the demand for a decisive outcome transcends political divides. While they are critical of current policies, they position themselves as part of the national camp and would support Prime Minister Netanyahu, provided he implements a decisive policy.
Their proposed solution for Gaza is "conquest, expulsion, settlement," a vision Kirshberg believes is necessary given the post-October 7 reality. Patsiniash Valdman sees this as a moral imperative, urging the opening of gates for Gazans to leave, regardless of their destination. They also criticize US involvement since the war's start, arguing it has limited Israel's operational freedom, even under a friendly administration. The reservists aim to bring their vision to the political arena through the Identity Party, emphasizing their commitment to achieving victory.
Mentioned
