Israel's Sea of Galilee Tourism Suffers Amid 'Brain-Eating Amoeba' Fears
Translated & summarized from Walla by baba
Local officials in Tiberias are protesting a Ministry of Health order to post warning signs about the "brain-eating amoeba" at the Sea of Galilee, fearing it will harm tourism. The directive follows the death of a child in September after swimming at Kursi beach, though experts debate the amoeba's source. Tourism to the lake has already dropped significantly this year due to war-related closures and public fear. Authorities have hired a former health official to review the situation before further discussions with government ministries.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Mayor Yossi Nevah calls Ministry of Health "brain-eating amoeba" warnings a "death sentence" for Sea of Galilee tourism.
- Tourism at the Sea of Galilee has dropped by approximately 800,000 visitors this year compared to last.
- The directive follows the September death of a 9-year-old boy from an amoebic brain infection after swimming at Kursi beach.
- Experts disagree on whether the amoeba poses a significant risk in the open lake or is more likely in closed water systems.
- Local authorities have hired former Ministry of Health official Itamar Grotto to review the situation.
- Since 2022, three other amoeba infection cases have been diagnosed in Israel, not linked to the Sea of Galilee.
Local officials are decrying a Ministry of Health directive to post warning signs about the "brain-eating amoeba" Naegleria fowleri at the Sea of Galilee's beaches, arguing it will devastate the already struggling tourism industry. Yossi Nevah, Mayor of Tiberias and Chairman of the Kinneret Cities Association, called the requirement a "death sentence for tourism" on the lake, especially as the bathing season concludes. The directive follows the September death of a 9-year-old boy from Pardes Hanna, who contracted a rare amoebic brain infection after swimming at Kinneret's Kursi beach.
Tourism figures for the region show a significant decline, with approximately 2.5 million visitors to the Kinneret's 16 beaches this year, compared to 3.3 million last year, a drop of about 800,000. This decline is attributed to both the closure of beaches due to the "Roaring Lion" war from February 28 to April 9, which included the busy Passover and Eid al-Fitr holidays, and the subsequent fear generated by the boy's death.
While the Ministry of Health insists its actions align with international protocols and that the risk of infection is "very low," local authorities are pushing back. Nevah criticized the timing of the signs, noting the season's end, and urged the ministry to engage in professional dialogue rather than making unilateral decisions that could unnecessarily frighten the public. He suggested that if the ministry intended to close the lake, it should do so officially and compensate businesses.
Experts are divided on the source of the infection. Professor Moshe Gofen, former director of the Kinneret Research Laboratory, suggested the amoeba is more likely to thrive in closed water systems, like showers or neglected pools, where water temperatures can rise, rather than in the open lake. He pointed to previous cases in Israel linked to such environments. The Ministry of Health, however, stated that the Kursi beach was the only freshwater source the boy visited and that the amoeba is naturally found in freshwater, thriving under specific environmental conditions.
In response to the controversy, local authorities have hired Professor Itamar Grotto, former Deputy Director General of the Ministry of Health, to review the data and formulate a professional stance for upcoming discussions with the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Health. Since 2022, three other cases of amoeba infection have been diagnosed in Israel, none linked to the Sea of Galilee, with one case possibly linked to a winter puddle and two others in summer 2024 potentially linked to a water park on the lake's shore.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Centre 2
